Sam Darnold or Drew Lock? Richard Sherman weighs in on QB situation
The Seahawks legend believes the context of the defenses each quarterback has faced is important to consider.
Sam Darnold (right) and Drew Lock of the Seattle Seahawks prior to a playoff game against the Los Angeles Rams on Jan. 25, 2026, in Seattle. (Steph Chambers/Getty Images)
(Steph Chambers/Getty Images)
From the outside looking in, it would appear that the Seattle Seahawks have a quarterback controversy, or at the very least that one is starting to brew.
The chase for 2K: Seahawks’ JSN on pace for history
The Seahawks are 2-4 under usual starter Sam Darnold this season, which excludes the season opener when he exited with a glute injury after one series. Darnold has completed 60.2% of his passes for 1,478 yards and 10 TDs in those six-plus games, but the glaring number is the nine interceptions he has thrown, which includes two that ultimately cost Seattle chances to win against Washington and Denver.
Meanwhile, Seattle is 4-0 under Drew Lock, including the season opener when he came in to relieve Darnold. Lock has competed an efficient 73.1% for 837 yards, seven touchdowns and no interceptions, though he has lost two fumbles.
The Seahawks have a bye this week before an important NFC West showdown at the San Francisco 49ers in Week 12. Darnold, who has missed the past two games with rib and quad injuries, could be healthy enough to play by then. So, who should be Seattle’s starting quarterback be for that game against their rival if Darnold is ready to go? Seahawks legend Richard Sherman weighed in during his latest edition of “The Richard Sherman Podcast.”
“This is such an unprecedented situation for the Seahawks and Mike Macdonald. Because how often do you have a quarterback who just helped you win a Super Bowl in this league and now you’re questioning whether you should bench him or not for a guy who has not had a ton of success in the National Football League over the long-term?” the five-time All-Pro cornerback said.
Prior to this year, Lock had never won more than four games in a season as a starting quarterback in the NFL. He’s essentially already reached that mark with his three starts plus the win in the season opener under his belt. And to Lock’s credit, the 85.8 QBR he’s posted in his limited time is the best in the NFL and his 90.8 passer grade from Pro Football Focus trails only MVP candidate Joe Burrow from the Cincinnati Bengals.
But Sherman sees an important caveat to what Lock has done, especially when comparing it side by side with Darnold.
“Sure, he’s had success this season not turning the football over, did enough for this team to win ballgames, made some incredible plays and some incredible throws in this game (against Las Vegas), but has not been really challenged with great defenses yet,” Sherman said. “It’s hard to compare what Sam Darnold does against a Denver Broncos or San Francisco 49ers coached defense. And then you watch Drew Lock against the Arizona Cardinals and the Raiders and then you’re like: he’s better.
“Not everything is created equal, especially in the National Football League.”
The Patriots’ 17th-ranked scoring defense is the best Lock has faced in his four wins. The other three have come against the Cardinals and Raiders, who are tied for the league’s worst scoring defense. The Cardinals and Raiders also held Seattle more than a touchdown below their season averages in points allowed in Lock’s past two starts.
As for Darnold, four of his games have come against teams with defenses ranked 11th or better in points allowed, which includes beating the third-ranked Chiefs in perhaps his best performance of the season. He’s also faced defenses ranked 20th (Commanders) and 29th (Chargers) in points allowed.
Ultimately, Sherman believes the job should still belong to the quarterback that helped Seattle hoist the Lombardi Trophy at the end of last season.
“They have a bye week coming up. I would expect Sam Darnold to be healthy after that bye week,” Sherman said. “I would expect Mike Macdonald to get in front of that podium and address the situation and say: Are you guys crazy? This is Sam Darnold who has won a Super Bowl for us just this past season. Do we give Drew Lock a ton of credit? No question about it, but the circumstances are different.”
Drew Lock is winning, but is there REALLY a QB controversy in Seattle? 👀@RSherman_25 weighs in on Lock vs. Sam Darnold—and why the defenses they’ve faced matter.
Who should start when Darnold is healthy?
Full Week 10 episode is out now on YouTube!https://t.co/hf45HNaH9Q pic.twitter.com/R7NKVFupBF
— Richard Sherman Podcast (@RShermanPodcast) November 16, 2026
Watch Richard Sherman’s take on the Seahawks’ quarterback situation in the embed above.
More on the Seattle Seahawks
• Seattle Seahawks Injury Updates: The latest on RT Abraham Lucas
• Stacy Rost: Seahawks’ offense getting closer to winning formula
• Instant Reaction: Seahawks dominate second half to beat Raiders






Comments
0 Comments