Petriello details how M’s can improve defense
Seattle was last in MLB in Statcast's defensive metrics in 2026.
Seattle Mariners center fielder Julio Rodríguez makes a catch during a game against the Kansas City Royals on May 24, 2026, in Kansas City, Missouri. (Jamie Squire/Getty Images)
(Jamie Squire/Getty Images)
With less than two weeks remaining before an expected lockout, the Mariners added their third baseman, trading for Maikel Garcia from the Kansas City Royals.
Offense is always welcome, but this year the priority with the position-player acquisition is defense. Garcia, a Gold Glove winner in 2025, checks that box as a major defensive upgrade at the hot corner.
Drayer: What the Maikel Garcia trade means for Seattle Mariners
Defense was largely absent from the team in 2026 as it graded out at or near the bottom of the league defensive metrics. And before Seattle made the deal for Garcia, Bump and Stacy got a closer look at the state of the Mariners’ defense with MLB.com’s Mike Petriello on Tuesday afternoon.
“If you look at the Statcast defensive metrics, they were dead last in baseball at minus-59 (runs below average),” he said. “When you have the president of baseball using the word ‘atrocious,’ that gives you confidence the numbers are matching what you see.”
Unfortunately, the defense alone did not fall into the atrocious category for the Mariners last season as they also finished as the slowest team in baseball in both sprint speed and average home-to-first time. Not a good combination according to Petriello, who focuses on Statcast and Baseball Savant data in his work.
“You look at the Brewers and you look at the Rays and it wasn’t really about small ball, but it was about, athleticism and speed and defense and being able to win it a whole bunch of ways,” he said. “I think if the game is going to go in that direction, you can’t be the slowest team and you can’t be the weakest fielding team.”
It was a dramatic turn for the Mariners but one with solid whys according to Petriello, who pointed to not enough being done the previous offseason as one of the reasons for the downturn.
“The thing about speed and defense is if the names stay the same then guys tend to age, and if they are not bringing in guys that can do the job behind them, then they are not going be able to find a way to improve,” he said, noting a decline with J.P. Crawford and Randy Arozarena not being strong defensively to start with.
Two stars who could rebound defensively
There were also the massive struggles of Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodríguez, which Petriello outlined in an article with Raleigh’s numbers taking a dive across the board and Rodriguez losing more than a step in center. In the case of Raleigh, he saw a myriad of reasons why his defense suffered.
“I don’t want to completely speculate on health because I’m not there, but would that be surprising in any way to find out that an injured shoulder might impact your ability to frame?” he asked. “And I also look at him, if you go back to the previous season, you go and look at all the plate appearances he took not only through the year, but all the way into the playoffs.
“He played a lot of baseball. That’s really hard to keep up. So between that, a short offseason with the playoff run, potential injury issues (and) I imagine some great deal of frustration with the way his offensive season was going, it’s not that hard for me to see him coming back and rebounding, and saying: That was just a bad year all around. I’m going to flush it. I’m going to, if not be as elite as I was, at least be a plus.”
He finds Rodríguez’s performance to be a bit more of a mystery.
“He declined (in speed) a little bit, but going from 93rd percentile to 85th, that’s still really good, right? It’s not that he couldn’t get to the ball and he’s certainly not old,” Petriello said. “The reactions were down. Teams like the Rays have really keyed in on the fact that you can’t teach guys to be faster in terms of foot speed, but you can teach them to get off to better jumps, better reactions. That’s a huge part of what they did. For Julio, it went the opposite direction to below average, and that’s a big deal. It might not sound like much, but that’s the difference between getting to a ball or not.”
Petriello is optimistic Rodríguez can rebound from a poor defensive year in part because he still has plus running speed.
“I feel like he can be better, Raleigh can be better and they have to be because you cannot fix this entire problem with external players. The supply is just not out there,” he said.
Defensive help in the OF available
Petriello does not believe the Mariners will be able to land free agent Seiya Suzuki, who would appear to be a perfect fit for them and half the league. Setting their sights a little bit lower, he could see Suzuki’s teammate with the Cubs, Ian Happ, as perhaps being an answer at one of the corners.
“He’s a four-time Gold Glove winner,” he said. “He is not by himself going to turn around the fate of the franchise, but I do think he solves a couple of problems. He’s a competent hitter, pretty solid outfielder, and I think that’s the range they are going to be going.”
Outside acquisitions will be important but likely mean little if there is not significant bounceback with those who under performed in 2026. If they get improvement in that regard, they could find themselves back on the path they believed they would be on in ’26. And if they get into the postseason, everything could be on the table.
“If Milwaukee can do it, if other teams aside from the Dodgers can do it, Seattle can do it too,” Petriello said. “It’s got to come down to a good franchise with their superstars playing well. I don’t want to keep going back to Raleigh and Arozarena, but for all of the small-ball stuff around the Brewers, don’t forget they have Jacob Misiorowski, who’s the best pitcher alive right now, and they have Brice Turang, who’s hitting like an MVP, and Jackson Chourio, who I think might be the next kind of MVP guy. You need your stars to be stars. Everything else falls after that.”
Hear the full conversation at this link or in the audio player in this story. Tune in to Bump and Stacy weekdays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. or find the podcast on the Seattle Sports app.
Seattle Mariners news and more
• Passan: Maikel Garcia ‘checks every box’ for Seattle Mariners
• Reports: Seattle Mariners add two pitchers on minor league deals
• Randy Arozarena wins first career Silver Slugger






Comments
0 Comments