ADVERTISEMENT

DANNY ONEIL

Do you want Greg Hardy in Seattle? It’s not a football question

Greg Hardy's history makes his prospective employment problematic and the reason news that the Seahawks are one of three teams pursuing him such a lightning rod.

Greg Hardy, who the Seahawks are reportedly interested in, was convicted of assault by a judge. (AP...

Greg Hardy, who the Seahawks are reportedly interested in, was convicted of assault by a judge. (AP)

(AP)

Do you want Greg Hardy on your football team?

That question actually has nothing to do with football. Not given Hardy’s history.

From a football standpoint, this is a no-brainer. Here’s a 26-year-old defensive lineman who not only totaled 15 sacks in 2013, but AVERAGED 8.3 sacks over his first four years in the league. That’s the kind of pass-rushing production that usually commands an eight-digit salary on the open market, and yet Hardy wound up with only half that on a short-term deal.

It’s Hardy’s history that makes his prospective employment so problematic, and the reason news that the Seahawks are one of three teams pursuing him such a lightning rod, though Seattle has not arranged a visit with Hardy as others reported. Seattle is simply looking into his background.

Whether you think Hardy should be a Seahawk has nothing to do with football and everything to do with the NFL’s tolerance of allegations of domestic violence, our country’s presumption of innocence and a professional’s ability to get a second chance.

Here are the facts of Hardy’s case. He was arrested in May after police were called to his apartment after 4 in the morning. There were conflicting accounts of what occurred based on 911 calls. Hardy was arrested, released on bond and in July stood at a bench trial where the judge found – beyond a reasonable doubt – that Hardy assaulted and threatened a woman described as his formal girlfriend.

ADVERTISEMENT

In North Carolina, a defendant found guilty in a bench trial is automatically granted the right to a jury trial in Superior Court, which Hardy’s attorney immediately sought. In the meantime, Hardy began preparing for the season.

In fact, he played in the Panthers’ first game, one day before video was published showing Ray Rice striking his then-fiancee in an Atlantic City elevator. Those images changed not only the national perception of the league’s policy on domestic violence, but the NFL’s implementation of it.

Hardy was not active for the team’s Week 2 game, and subsequently placed on the Commissioner’s Exempt list. He did not play again last season, though he did collect his entire $13 million salary.

In February – when Hardy’s jury trial was scheduled to begin – the case against Hardy was dismissed in North Carolina, the prosecutor in the case stating the alleged victim was unavailable and could not be issued a subpoena. The prosecutor stated it had “reliable information” that a civil settlement had been reached between Hardy and the alleged victim.

ADVERTISEMENT

What happened is easier to lay out than what should happen next. Hardy still could be punished by the league under the personal-conduct policy. Then again, Hardy’s actions took place before the league put new behavior guidelines were put in place and the courts have now ruled (twice) that the league can’t retroactively enforce its new disciplinary protocol.

But even if the league doesn’t punish Hardy, a team has a choice about whether this is the type of player it wants to employ. After all, a judge looked at the evidence and concluded Hardy had assaulted and threatened his former girlfriend while a jury of his peers never had a chance to look at the evidence.

And then there’s the whole question of second chances and time served. Hardy was unable to play for an entire season. He did, however, collect his full salary. He still faces the possibility of discipline from the league.

ADVERTISEMENT

Is this charge sufficient to keep an NFL team from employing him never again? Does the fact the case was eventually dismissed mean that he was any less guilty? And if he did commit the crimes he was accused of, how long should he sit out before he gets a chance to resume his career.

Those aren’t rhetorical questions. They’re all very real for the teams looking at Hardy, a group that reportedly includes the Seahawks.

Comments

0 Comments