Salk: Why Mariners’ Scott Servais is still ‘right manager for this team’

Oct 7, 2019, 5:05 PM
Mariners manager Scott Servais...
Mariners manager Scott Servais has won the second-most games in franchise history. (Getty)

Continuity in the manager position has not been a strength of the Mariners over their 43 seasons as a Major League Baseball franchise.

Surprising name could join M’s in 2020 in a sign of things to come

The Mariners have had 20 managers in their history. Lou Piniella held the job the longest at 10 seasons. Nobody else has reached five.

Well, at least until next year.

Current manager Scott Servais is already second on some notable lists when it comes to Mariners skippers – chiefly second-most wins (321) and second-longest tenure (648 games over four seasons). He also has the third-best winning percentage all-time among all M’s managers at .495, trailing only Piniella (.542) and his direct predecessor, Lloyd McClendon (.503).

And yet as the manager carousel begins around baseball, there is a bit of talk about whether Servais should get the chance to become just the second person ever to manage a fifth season with the Mariners. The main reason for that is the availability of Joe Maddon, who led the Cubs to the 2016 World Series championship but parted ways with Chicago at the end of the 2019 regular season.

Availability is one thing. Viability is another. But whether the Mariners could bring Maddon to town, would there even be reason for them to take Servais out of the managerial position?

“I am not in favor of firing Scott Servais,” 710 ESPN Seattle’s Mike Salk said recently on the debut edition of the weekly Brock and Salk podcast. “In fact, I’m in favor of giving him all the tools he needs because I think he did a heck of a job this year of building culture and letting these young kids grow up.

“… I want Scott to keep the job and we’ll see whether or not Joe Maddon goes somewhere else.”

Servais is in an interesting position. It’s not very often that a manager leads a team to a 68-94 record without finding himself on the hot seat. The Mariners’ front office wasn’t expecting a winner in 2019, however. It was the first season of a rebuild, and Servais didn’t have the same kind of talent on the mound, at the plate and in the field as he did in his first three seasons when he led the team to a combined 253-233 record (.521 winning percentage).

Salk said Servais has not only done what the Mariners have asked him to do but even produced better results than expected when faced with a tough task this year, especially when it came to player development with the big league club.

“They didn’t give him the resources to compete. Nobody thinks they did. This team did what they were supposed to do this year. They didn’t underperform; if anything, they probably won more games than some of us thought they would… and in the meantime I thought we saw some legitimate growth from some of the youngsters.

“First of all, the two catchers, neither of whom I think we expected it from, both grew and got better. (Omar) Narváez became a better defensive catcher and (Tom) Murphy turned himself into a pretty good offensive player, which nobody thought we would see, and as a platoon they were as good as any catcher out there in baseball, right? I liked what I saw from (shortstop) J.P. Crawford. The big deal with him was, can the defense improve? It did – he was a solid defensive shortstop. And then you got a little something out of the Austin Nolas and some of those guys this year. Throw in (outfielder) Kyle Lewis at the end of the season and I think you can make an argument that some of that stage is being set (for Seattle to be competitive in the future).”

Salk’s co-host, Brock Huard, said Servais’ tenure has given the Mariners something they’ve been missing since Piniella’s last season in Seattle in 2002.

“For the first time, this thing feels totally all-inclusive with the Mariners between (director of player development) Andy McKay, (general manager) Jerry Dipoto, Scott Servais – it actually feels like they’ve got some level of continuity and structure,” Huard said.

Salk and Huard agreed that when a name like Maddon is out there, most teams would have a conversation about whether or not to pursue him. They even related it to how Pete Carroll was hired as Seahawks head coach after Jim Mora had just one season at the helm of the team. But Servais isn’t Mora, and ultimately Salk feels the Mariners have the right guy in charge of their clubhouse and dugout.

“It’s doesn’t mean you don’t have the conversation (about Maddon) and I would expect Jerry Dipoto and (majority owner) John Stanton and (team president) Kevin Mather to have the conversation. I don’t think that’s a move they’re going to make because I think that they are happy with what they’re doing,” Salk said. “… I think (Servais) is a very good manager and in many ways the right manager for this team.”

You can hear the full conversation beginning at the 46:40 mark in the Brock and Salk podcast embedded below or at this link.

Subscribe to Brock and Salk on Apple Podcasts or Stitcher.

No starting pitcher.

Mariners Roof Report

Brought to you by
High 77° | Low 54°
No game today.

Brock and Salk podcast

Brock and Salk

Seahawks Jamal Adams...
Brent Stecker

How missing Jamal Adams has thrown Seahawks’ defense for a loop

Brock Huard explains why something that K.J. Wright pointed out about the impact of Jamal Adams missing from the Seahawks' defense jumps out.
3 days ago
Mariners Mitch Haniger...
Brent Stecker

Mariners’ Mitch Haniger has a lot riding on the rest of the season

Mitch Haniger slumped in September, complicating what the Mariners should do with him set to be a free agent this offseason.
3 days ago
Mariners Jarred Kelenic...
Brandon Gustafson

Is Mariners’ Jarred Kelenic back for good? 3 MLB insiders weigh in

Jarred Kelenic has produced in his short time back with the Mariners from Triple-A. We look at what MLB insiders Mike Blowers, Jeff Passan and Jon Morosi have to say about him.
4 days ago
Seahawks Boye Mafe...
Brandon Gustafson

K.J. Wright: Why, how Seahawks should play Boye Mafe more

Seahawks legend K.J. Wright thinks Seattle needs to be playing rookie LB Boye Mafe more going forward, especially on early downs.
4 days ago
Mariners Luis Castillo...
Brandon Gustafson

Dipoto: Mariners’ Julio extension ‘fired up’ Luis Castillo to sign long-term

The Mariners' extension with Luis Castillo may not have happened if not for Julio Rodríguez's megadeal, as Jerry Dipoto explained Thursday.
4 days ago
Mariners Julio Rodriguez, Eugenio Suarez...
Brandon Gustafson

Mariners’ Dipoto: Suárez returning to 3B, Julio update, Kelenic’s role

Jerry Dipoto shared updates on Eugenio Suárez and Julio Rodríguez and what Rodríguez's return to the Mariners means for Jarred Kelenic.
4 days ago
Salk: Why Mariners’ Scott Servais is still ‘right manager for this team’