Fann: 2 questions that will define Mariners’ ALDS chances vs Astros

Oct 10, 2022, 6:55 PM
Mariners Cal Raleigh Adam Frazier...
Cal Raleigh celebrates with Mariners teammate Adam Frazier after a June 6, 2022 home run in Houston. (Photo by Carmen Mandato/Getty Images)
(Photo by Carmen Mandato/Getty Images)

After getting two full days to celebrate the Mariners’ incredible Wild Card series win in Toronto, it’s time to turn the page to Houston and the upcoming ALDS against the Astros.

M’s Notebook: ALDS start can’t come soon enough for Logan Gilbert

Not to oversimplify what’s to come this week, but I do think there are two overarching questions that will define whether or not the Mariners are capable of pulling off the upset against their AL West rivals.

Here’s what I’ll be paying close attention to.

1. How will the Mariners structure their rotation?

We know it will be Logan Gilbert and Luis Castillo in Games 1 and 2, respectively, but what will come next? Will it be George Kirby in Game 3 before Gilbert once again in Game 4? Surely Luis Castillo would start Game 5 on three day’s rest, right?

That’s how I’d order it if it were up to me. But I’m curious to see what manager Scott Servais opts to do with Robbie Ray most notably, but also Marco Gonzales and potentially Chris Flexen.

You don’t need me to tell you that Robbie Ray was dreadful against Houston this season. Ray totaled a mere 10.2 innings over three starts, surrendering a whopping 13 runs with seven walks while striking out just seven. There’s no scenario where he should get a start in this series. That said, I think there’s tremendous value in having him as a left-on-left specialist as a power arm out of the bullpen. I’d be just fine with Servais using him in high-leverage situations against Yordan Álvarez or Kyle Tucker, the only two left-handed hitters in Houston’s lineup.

I think it’s possible Servais gives Game 3 to Gonzales, who quietly posted a quality start in three out of his four starts against Houston this season. Gonzales and Kirby could be in a piggyback situation as well.

Related: Why M’s could get creative with their pitchers in ALDS vs. Astros

It should also be noted, as Aaron Goldsmith pointed out on Twitter, that Chris Flexen never surrendered more than three runs in any of his five starts versus the Astros in 2022. He allowed just two runs in two of them and one run in another pair of them.

2. Will the lineup stay hot against Houston’s stellar pitching staff?

The Astros rank first in MLB with a 2.68 FIP since Sept. 15 (regular season only). Houston is led by expected AL Cy Young winner Justin Verlander, who posted a ridiculous 1.75 ERA and 5.9 WAR at age 39. He’s joined in the rotation by Framber Valdez (who is second behind Verlander in ESPN’s Cy Young prediction), Cristian Javier and Lance McCullers Jr. as Houston starters with a sub-3.00 ERA in 2022. Luis García was also dominant in his one start against Seattle this season (6 IP, 1 ER, 6 K back on May 29).

Seattle went just 7-12 against Houston in 19 regular season matchups, scoring two runs or less 11 times. The Mariners posted just one run four times and got shutout on three occasions. All seven of Seattle’s wins against Houston came when scoring at least five runs.

The M’s lineup was sensational in two games against the Blue Jays, scoring a combined 14 runs. That included production beyond the usual suspects with timely hits from Carlos Santana, Adam Frazier and J.P. Crawford. If you’re a believer in momentum, it’ll be easy to sell yourself on Seattle’s chances against Houston.

More Mariners coverage from Seattle Sports

Mariners Breakdown: The comeback, the sweep, and facing the Astros
Stecker: How did Mariners make it this far? Same reason they could keep going
Mariners ALDS schedule, Astros matchup and radio broadcast details
Drayer: Mariners put their stamp on playoffs with signature chaos
Video: Highlights from Mariners’ sweep with Seattle Sports radio calls
Mariners have no shortage of heroes in incredible sweep of Blue Jays

Joe Fann

Mariners White Sox Abreu...
Joe Fann

Fann: Astros just sent reminder to Mariners they’re not going anywhere

The Mariners should feel a sense of urgency to make another upgrade after the Astros signed former AL MVP José Abreu on Monday, writes Joe Fann.
13 hours ago
Seahawks Boye Mafe...
Joe Fann

Fann: 3 Seahawks X-factors for the remainder of the season

Getting contributions from three players on defense would give the Seahawks a big boost in the quest for the NFC West title down the stretch.
6 days ago
Mariners Brandon Nimmo...
Joe Fann

Fann: Surveying the Mariners top 3 options to complete their outfield

The Mariners' have two OF starters in Julio Rodríguez and Teoscar Hernández, and Joe Fann breaks down his top options for that third spot.
8 days ago
Seahawks Tariq Woolen Jordyn Brooks...
Joe Fann

Fann Mail: Do the Seahawks or Mariners have the brighter future?

Seattle Sports columnist Joe Fann answers your questions, including several on the Seahawks and Mariners each -- and a few about both.
12 days ago
Joe Fann

Fann: Seahawks’ loss to Bucs indicative of who they are on both sides

The Seahawks losing 21-16 to the Buccaneers was disappointing, but the performance was indicative of who they really are, Joe Fann says.
15 days ago
Mariners free agency Brandon Nimmo...
Joe Fann

Fann: Mariners free agent wish list for pivotal offseason in team history

Joe Fann goes through the options to improve the Mariners roster through free agency as they look to build upon two straight 90-win seasons.
20 days ago
Fann: 2 questions that will define Mariners’ ALDS chances vs Astros