Clayton: Why Seahawks didn’t need an upgrade for Russell Wilson’s backup

Apr 26, 2021, 12:46 PM

Seahawks Geno Smith...

Geno Smith will be Russell Wilson's backup QB for a third straight season. (Getty)


Backup quarterbacks are important in the NFL. If a contending team like the Seahawks loses its starter, chances of making the playoffs aren’t good.

Bumpus: The small-school WR Seahawks should consider drafting

Last week, the Seahawks re-signed Geno Smith to a minimum salary deal to return for a third year as Russell Wilson’s backup. He got a one-year, $1,212,500 contract that included a $137,500 signing bonus. The contract counts as $987,500 against the cap.

Critics said the Seahawks should have gone out, paid more and got a better backup than Smith, but that’s not the trend in the NFL. Around the league, only 16 teams are paying more than the minimum for a backup. Seven of the 12 playoff teams from 2020 – New Orleans, Cleveland, Buffalo, Chicago, Green Bay, Kansas City and Washington – have backups making more than the minimum salary. In the case of the Packers, they have last year’s first-round choice Jordan Love making $3.095 million on his rookie contract.

Smith is just fine as Wilson’s backup. He’s 30 years old and has the experience of 41 NFL starts. In two years with the Seahawks, he has only played one game and thrown just five passes, completing four. But he’s a smaller, mobile quarterback who fits in the Wilson offense should Seattle need to turn to him.

Look around the NFC West. Nate Sudfeld is the backup in San Francisco. He’s on a one-year, $990,000 minimum salary deal. The Arizona Cardinals signed Colt McCoy, who is making the same money as Smith, to be Kyler Murray’s backup. It’s a one-year, $1,212,500 deal. John Wolford is the Los Angeles Rams backup and he’s only making $630,000 a year.

This is a quarterback-driven league. To be a playoff contender, you have to have a top quarterback. Those quarterbacks are at the top of the pay scale because they are that important. Because those quarterbacks eat up so much of the salary cap, teams have to make compromises to save cap room. And it’s even more pronounced this year with the cap down 8 percent at $182.5 million.

Running back, guard and backup quarterback seem to be the positions making the sacrifices with the smaller cap. Among last year’s playoff teams, only Chicago, Cleveland and Green Bay paying more than $2.5 million for a backup. The Seahawks’ re-signing of Geno Smith was just fine.

Follow John Clayton on Twitter.

More from John: Seahawks ‘bargain shopped’ but filled out CB nicely

The John Clayton Memorial Fund

Benefitting the Multiple Sclerosis Society

The Professor's Notes

John Clayton hosted a daily video breaking down the NFL

John Clayton

John Clayton Memorial Fund...

No Author

John Clayton Memorial Fund benefiting the Multiple Sclerosis Society

Seattle Sports and Bonneville International are honored to announce the “John Clayton Memorial Fund.” The John Clayton Memorial Fund will benefit the Multiple Sclerosis Society.

2 years ago

Seahawks Russell Wilson, DK Metcalf...

John Clayton

Clayton: What’s next for Seahawks after kicking off ‘major’ rebuild

After some major moves, John Clayton breaks down what the next things to watch for with the Seahawks are heading into the new league year.

2 years ago

Seahawks Russell Wilson...

John Clayton

Clayton: Won’t be easy for Seahawks to replace Wilson after surprising trade

After a surprising trade he never thought would happen, John Clayton shares his immediate reaction to the Seahawks' trade of Russell Wilson.

2 years ago

Seahawks Action Green...

John Clayton

Clayton: Why you shouldn’t worry about salary cap with Seahawks this offseason

Seahawks fans and followers are worried about how they can re-sign players and stay under the salary cap. John Clayton says they shouldn't be.

2 years ago

Seahawks Russell Wilson, Pete Carroll...

John Clayton

Clayton: The big news from Seahawks, NFC West as combine begins

Wednesday was a big news day for the Seahawks and the NFC West. John Clayton breaks down what's going on in Seattle's division.

2 years ago

Seahawks Rashaad Penny Russell Wilson Chris Carson...

John Clayton

Clayton: How RBs in NFL Draft should help Seahawks this offseason

The Seahawks should be looking to bring Rashaad Penny back, but a loaded class of running backs is likely to help them in a few ways.

2 years ago

Clayton: Why Seahawks didn’t need an upgrade for Russell Wilson’s backup