O’Neil: Kaepernick’s availability shows how NFL teams can value popularity over performance

May 17, 2017, 5:05 AM | Updated: 9:28 am

colin kaepernick, seahawks, seattle seahawks...

Has the NFL blackballed Colin Kaepernick as a result of his protest? (AP)


Personnel decisions shouldn’t be a popularity contest.

Not when it comes to a player’s ability on the field. Not when it comes to his character off of it.

Seems like now is a good time to offer that reminder as the Seahawks consider adding Colin Kaepernick, a possibility that coach Pete Carroll acknowledged Monday on 710 ESPN Seattle with “Brock and Salk.”

Adding Kaepernick as a backup quarterback should be a no-brainer for the Seahawks. He’s better than current backup Trevone Boykin. Kaepernick is a possibility for Seattle only because so many other teams either refuse to consider him or are so afraid of angering a segment of their fan base that they won’t add a former Super Bowl starter.

That’s what politics will do. At least in today’s NFL.

Kaepernick’s decision against standing for the national anthem last season means that his addition would aggravate, maybe even enrage, a significant portion of any NFL team’s fan base. That’s not a very good reason not to sign him, though. Not unless you’re an NFL team that wants to use public opinion as a weather vane for all decision-making.

Michael Bennett says Seahawks are a perfect fit for Kaepernick

It may seem like that’s already happening. After all, any discussion of drafting or signing a controversial player becomes a public referendum on whether that’s the kind of person who should be in the NFL, and teams seem more willing than ever to let the opinions of their fan base render some players unemployable.

That’s not so troubling when the player in question is someone like Ray Rice or Greg Hardy. It’s more problematic when it comes to someone like Kaepernick, who didn’t do anything except exercise a constitutional right to express his opinion. How that opinion is characterized will tell you more about the politics of the person offering the description than they do about what Kaepernick did as a person or his future as a player.

Those who support his anthem protest will call him an activist bringing attention to the mistreatment of people in color. Those repulsed by his refusal to stand for the anthem last season will call him unpatriotic or even hypocritical after he revealed he did not vote in the presidential election.

Clayton: Biggest question with Kaepernick, Seahawks is money

Kaepernick is unavoidably political at a time when antagonism is at an all-time high, not just between the two major political parties but among our population in general.

We’ve lost any ability to find a middle ground. To recognize that it’s possible to disagree with what Kaepernick did without being a racist, and it’s equally OK for a team to hire Kaepernick while disagreeing with his decision not to stand for the anthem last season, something he has already said he won’t continue in 2017.

And let’s be clear: Politics is why Kaepernick is still available. If there are jobs for two McCowns in this league, there’s certainly space to accommodate a guy who’s only four years removed from starting in a Super Bowl and having ESPN’s Ron Jaworski proclaim a chance that Kaepernick could become the greatest quarterback ever.

The fact that Kaepernick hasn’t been to the playoffs since then and has only won four of his last 24 starts explains why he’s no longer a starter. The fact that he’s not on a roster is because no team thinks the chance he will resurrect his career is worth the antagonism his signing will arouse.

Salk: Signing Kaepernick should be a “no-brainer” for the Seahawks

That’s a businessman’s perspective, though. Or a politician’s, and that’s a terrible way to run a football team because it substitutes popularity for morality. If every personnel decision boils down to a question of a player’s talent versus the trouble he’ll bring, a team is going to assemble a roster full of the most talented players that its fan base will tolerate as opposed to finding the players that fit within their employment criteria.

And that’s the most important thing for a team to have: a criteria. A framework for evaluating whether a given player fits, an assessment that takes into account on-field ability and off-field behavior.

Yet it seems that teams have become so accustomed to gauging popular opinion to determine whether a player is employable that they’ve stopped using their own criteria to make that decision.

Danny and Gallant Show

Wyman & Bob

Danny ONeil

Seahawks Quandre Diggs...

Danny O'Neil

O’Neil: Seahawks have uncertainty with a player ‘holding in,’ but it’s not Quandre Diggs

While Quandre Diggs appears to be the third Seahawks player to "hold-in" during training camp, Danny O'Neil writes that it's Duane Brown whose future is up in the air.

2 years ago

Follow @dannyoneil...

Danny O'Neil

AZ Good AZ it Gets

SPONSORED – Phoenix was the place where the rest of the country found out that Seattle fans took their enthusiasm on the road with them. That was 2013. It’s also the place where I discovered how restorative a desert vacation can be. That was 2015. Let’s start with the screaming. That’s what caught everyone’s attention […]

2 years ago

Mariners Jarred Kelenic...

Danny O'Neil

O’Neil: Mariners aren’t handing the spotlight over to Seahawks just yet

This is the time of year that Seattle tends to shift its focus to the gridiron, but the Mariners are still commanding attention.

2 years ago

Seahawks Duane Brown...

Danny O'Neil

O’Neil: When Seahawks decide not to extend players, they’re rarely wrong

If you think the Seahawks must sign Duane Brown to an extension, when's the last time they opted against re-signing someone and it came back to bite them?

2 years ago

Follow @dannyoneil...

Danny O'Neil

Oh, LA, LA!

Week 15, Dec. 19: Seattle at Los Angeles Rams, SoFi Stadium, 1:25 p.m. Pacific SPONSORED – Maybe it was fitting that the opening act for the first pro-football game I covered in Los Angeles was a rock band I loved as a teenager. There’s no place that makes me think of growing up more than […]

2 years ago

Follow @dannyoneil...

Danny O'Neil

Star in a Lone Star Adventure

Week 14, Dec. 12: Seattle at Houston Texans, NRG Stadium, 10 a.m. Pacific SPONSORED – Enchiladas and greatness. That’s what I think of in Texas. The enchiladas are pretty straightforward. They’re so delicious at El Tiempo Cantina that it’s hard to take a bite without closing my eyes. There are three locations though the one […]

2 years ago

O’Neil: Kaepernick’s availability shows how NFL teams can value popularity over performance