Analysis: Where will the coaching carousel land this time?

Dec 30, 2021, 6:51 PM | Updated: Dec 31, 2021, 8:55 am
Chicago Bears head coach Matt Nagy is interviewed by ESPN's Lisa Salters at halftime of an NFL foot...

Chicago Bears head coach Matt Nagy is interviewed by ESPN's Lisa Salters at halftime of an NFL football game between the Bears and the Minnesota Vikings Monday, Dec. 20, 2021, in Chicago. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)

(AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)

Just like the Super Bowl, the draft, and the Jets missing the playoffs, there is another ritual in every NFL season.

The coaching carousel.

It’s spinning already with two openings, in Las Vegas and Jacksonville, forced by the departures of two disgraced coaches, Jon Gruden and Urban Meyer. It might also hit in Chicago, Minneapolis, Charlotte and New York. There are even rumblings that one of the best pro coaches of the last decade or so, Pete Carroll in Seattle, might have worn out his welcome.

Let’s dismiss that one; Carroll has earned the right to determine when he will leave the Seahawks. Yes, he’s the oldest coach in the NFL and this has been his worst season. But Carroll has a way of figuring out things, just like Sean Payton in New Orleans, John Harbaugh in Baltimore, and Mike Tomlin in Pittsburgh. All elite coaches with Super Bowl rings whose teams are struggling. None deserves to be dismissed.

As for the others, here’s a closer look – presuming the likes of David Culley in Houston, Dan Campbell in Detroit and Vic Fangio in Denver are safe.

Asked if he worries about job security, Fangio says: “I don’t. And I know you think that’s a standard answer. But for a lot of reasons, I do not worry about it. And those reasons are personal to me. But do I acknowledge that it’s certainly out there and could happen? Absolutely. But do I worry about it? I absolutely do not worry about it, for many, many reasons.”


This seems the most likely change, though Nagy has a winning record in his four seasons, 33-32 through last week’s comeback victory at Seattle. The main issues in Chicago have been:

— The lack of development at quarterback. This will be Justin Fields’ team moving forward, regardless who is the coach. But the decisions made on Mitchell Trubisky, Nick Foles — the winning QB last Sunday — and Andy Dalton have caused regression on offense.

— A defense that also has regressed from a big-play unit of near-championship caliber to a so-so unit.

— A severe lack of discipline in all aspects of on-field performance.

Former Eagles coach Doug Pederson would appear to be a wise option if Nagy is released.


There’s little doubt that Zimmer is a solid coach, but his talented team has underperformed and struggles in close games. Simply put, the Vikings can’t finish.

While Zimmer almost certainly would be gobbled up as a defensive coordinator should he become available, his D hasn’t been notable in Minnesota.

There’s also a question of whether, after eight years there with a good record but diminishing returns, whether it’s time for a fresh approach.


Late in his second consecutive losing season in Carolina, the man who turned around Temple and Baylor in college heard “Fire Rhule” chants on Sunday when the Panthers were routed by the injury-ravaged Buccaneers. In fairness to Rhule, the team started 3-0 and then lost its most important player, running back Christian McCaffrey. The Panthers never have been the same.

Odds are Rhule, in the second year of a $60 million contract, gets another season at least. He insists things aren’t so depressing.

“There is a process that is happening underneath and everyone is like, ‘It’s not working, Matt. It’s not working, Matt,’ But when I see all of the good things that are happening, I think it is,” he says.


Very similar to Rhule’s situation, the Giants coach is getting all sorts of heat at the end of his second losing season. This year was all about developing Daniel Jones, but the quarterback’s neck injury, the sidelining of some key players throughout the offense, and a general malaise in recent games has added to the criticism.

New York has not scored more than 10 points in the first half, an indictment of preparation as well as execution. He also is the third straight coaching hire the Giants might have missed on: Ben McAdoo, Pat Shurmur and Judge.

He probably deserves one more shot, but the uncertainty with Jones is an albatross for the entire franchise.


The Gruden redux was a flop, ending ignominiously. The Raiders could use someone less mercurial and able to deal with the modern locker room. A strong voice with a winning pedigree in the NFL seems best. Someone from the same mold as a Tomlin or Payton.

Too bad the team moved on from Jack Del Rio in 2018 when it went after Gruden.


This one should be easy for owner Shad Khan. Don’t go with a college coach, don’t go with the big name out there who has no NFL cred, and don’t ignore that Trevor Lawrence needs a quarterback whisperer.

Former Jaguars QB Byron Leftwich, now the offensive coordinator in Tampa Bay, and Chiefs standout OC Eric Bieniemy, critical in the development of Patrick Mahomes, fit the bill. As would an available Super Bowl winner, Pederson.


AP Pro Football Writer Arnie Stapleton and Sports Writer Steve Reed contributed.


More AP NFL coverage: and

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Boston Celtics forward Grant Williams, left, jokes with center Al Horford, right, as the NBA basket...
Associated Press

NBA unveils No. 6 patch to honor Bill Russell across league

CANTON, Mass. (AP) — As the longest-tenured player on the Celtics, Marcus Smart has been in Boston long enough to appreciate what Bill Russell meant to the team, the city and the country. “We’ve heard things like ‘pioneer,’ ‘trailblazer,'” Smart said Monday while wearing a patch honoring the Celtics Hall of Famer who died this […]
16 hours ago
Chicago Bulls head coach Billy Donovan, center, DeMar DeRozan (11) and Zach LaVine laugh as they po...
Associated Press

Bulls set sights higher, look to build on run to playoffs

CHICAGO (AP) — Zach LaVine had quite the offseason. The Chicago Bulls’ two-time All-Star and Olympic gold medalist landed the richest contract in franchise history when he agreed to a $215 million, five-year contract. He and his wife, Hunter, welcomed their first child, a son named Saint Thomas. LaVine also had arthroscopic surgery on his […]
16 hours ago
Charlotte Hornets guard LiAngelo Ball poses for a photographer during the NBA basketball team's med...
Associated Press

Hornets enter training camp; Miles Bridges’ future uncertain

CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — Miles Bridges’ future with the Charlotte Hornets remains uncertain as the team prepares to open training camp on Tuesday. Bridges, the team’s leading scorer last season, was charged with three counts of felony domestic violence in June. According to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office, Bridges allegedly assaulted the mother […]
16 hours ago
FILE - Cleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett runs during an NFL football practice in Berea, ...
Associated Press

Browns’ Garrett in accident, injuries not life-threatening

CLEVELAND (AP) — Cleveland Browns All-Pro defensive end Myles Garrett did not suffer life-threatening injuries after he was involved in a one-car accident following practice Monday. The team said Garrett was taken to a hospital, but did not give any specific details about his injuries or condition. The Browns said they are gathering more information. […]
16 hours ago
Alabama linebacker Will Anderson Jr. (31) celebrates a sack against Vanderbilt during the second ha...
Associated Press

No. 2 Alabama faces 3-game stretch of ranked foe

Alabama has mostly breezed through the first month of the season, with one big scare and three games that were frightfully but predictably easy. How good is ‘Bama, really? Check back in a few weeks. The second-ranked Crimson Tide (4-0, 1-0 Southeastern Conference) start a three-game stretch against ranked teams with Saturday’s visit to No. […]
16 hours ago
New Orleans Pelicans power forward Zion Williamson (1) jokes with David Griffin, executive vice pre...
Associated Press

For Zion, Kawhi, Murray and more, the wait is finally over

Kawhi Leonard was in the Los Angeles Clippers’ facility on Monday. That wasn’t exactly a surprise development. The news was his attire. He was wearing a basketball uniform. Finally. Welcome back, Kawhi. You too, Denver’s Jamal Murray, Brooklyn’s Ben Simmons, New Orleans’ Zion Williamson, the Clippers’ John Wall and plenty of others around the NBA. […]
16 hours ago
Analysis: Where will the coaching carousel land this time?