Mariners legend Harold Reynolds: May be time for MLB to ‘legislate’ the shift

Jun 30, 2019, 12:59 PM

Shifting three or more players to one side of the infield is a regularity in the MLB today. (Getty)...

Shifting three or more players to one side of the infield is a regularity in the MLB today. (Getty)


Former Mariners All-Star Harold Reynolds still keeps a close eye on the game of baseball as an analyst for the MLB Network. And as an ex-player who spent his entire career playing second base, it’s no surprise that he some thoughts on the infield shifts that are being employed more and more to defend against pull-heavy hitters.

Kelenic headlines 3 Mariners prospects to play in MLB Futures Game

It might be a surprise that Reynolds’ opinion on the shift has changed, however.

“I was always a proponent (that) you can shift all you want, it’s up to the hitter to hit the ball the other way,” Reynolds told 710 ESPN Seattle’s Bob, Groz and Tom, “but clearly there’s no interest in that and they’re not teaching guys that as much.”

Reynolds thinks it’s time baseball does something about it.

“I kind of feel like they need to legislate (to) no shifting,” he said.

The MLB is setting records left and right this year for home runs, something that may be a result of the way the league’s baseballs are now being constructed. Hitters have been putting more emphasis into launch angles and other ways to maximize their power numbers in recent years, as well, and some teams are shoehorning power hitters into their lineups at the expense of defense. For example, the Milwaukee Brewers have used lumbering corner infielders Mike Moustakas and Travis Shaw as second basemen during this season and last despite neither having any prior experience at the position.

Reynolds explained why he doesn’t think that adds up to a compelling game for fans to watch.

“It’s all about the long ball (now). When the ball’s not in play, it’s not a good game, and that’s where we’re at right now,” Reynolds said. “I think also it’s taking away a lot of athleticism. We see a guy like Mike Moustakas or Shaw with Milwaukee, those guys are playing second base now, and those are third basemen that are hitting 20-plus home runs. I think we’ve lost a lot of the athleticism (to the game) – the pivot doesn’t matter, there’s a slide rule that doesn’t affect guys, so there’s some rules I think need to change to get the game more athletic.

“We’re seeing a lot of home runs and the ball not in play quite as much. I’m not sure that’s good for the game.”

Reynolds also shared his thoughts on the Mariners’ rebuild and much more during the segment, which you can listen to in the player embedded in this post or download in podcast form here.

Are Mariners ‘winning’ trades Jerry Dipoto has made during rebuild?

Mariners Roof Report

Brought to you by
Slight Chance Rain Showers then Mostly Cloudy
High 62° | Low 51°
No game today.

Bob, Groz and Tom

Seahawks RB Chris Carson...

Brent Stecker

Heaps: Bench Chris Carson? Seahawks need him running to make playoffs

Seahawks running back Chris Carson is struggling with fumbles, and it's imperative he corrects the issue, says Jake Heaps. "If this team is going to go to the playoffs, they have to have Chris Carson running the football."

5 years ago

The Groz at T-Mobile Park...

Brent Stecker

Watch: The Groz throws out the 1st pitch before Mariners-Astros game

Dave "The Groz" Grosby was honored by the Mariners on Tuesday night by throwing out the ceremonial first pitch. Check out video, photos and more from his big night here.

5 years ago

Bob, Groz and Tom... Staff

Highlights from The Groz’s last show on Bob, Groz and Tom

Dave "The Groz" Grosby signed off as a full-time Seattle sports radio host Friday on Bob, Groz and Tom with visits from several notable names from his career.

5 years ago

The Groz... Staff

Watch: Members of the Seattle sports media pay tribute to The Groz

Watch a special tribute to 710 ESPN Seattle's The Groz featuring messages from members of the Seattle sports media to commemorate his 29 years as a daily host in the market.

5 years ago

The Groz...

Brent Stecker

The Groz’s final show on Bob, Groz and Tom airs Friday at noon

Dave "The Groz" Grosby will finish up his 29-year career as a daily Seattle sports radio host on Friday from noon to 3 p.m. on 710 ESPN Seattle's Bob, Groz and Tom.

5 years ago

Mariners OF Kyle Lewis...

Brent Stecker

What sets Mariners OF Kyle Lewis apart from other prospects?

Mariners outfielder Kyle Lewis hit his fifth home run in eight games in the big leagues on Wednesday. ROOT Sports analyst Mike Blowers talked to Bob, Groz and Tom about Lewis and what makes him stand out.

5 years ago

Mariners legend Harold Reynolds: May be time for MLB to ‘legislate’ the shift