Why Domingo Santana’s defense is most concerning for the Mariners

May 2, 2019, 3:32 PM
Mariners OF Domingo Santana has struggled in his transition to left field from right. (AP)...
Mariners OF Domingo Santana has struggled in his transition to left field from right. (AP)

Defense has been an especially prevalent complaint about the Seattle Mariners this season, and they have three players ranked in the bottom seven in the league in defensive WAR: left fielder Domingo Santana, center fielder Mallex Smith and shortstop Tim Beckham.

Servais: Mariners 3B Kyle Seager close to rehab assignment in minors

Shannon Drayer, Mariners insider for 710 ESPN Seattle, talked to John Clayton on Thursday and explained that while the defensive issues of Smith and Beckham aren’t exactly welcome, Santana’s performance in the field is what is most alarming.

“It’s a problem and it’s one that they’ve got to evaluate not just for now but for the future,” Drayer said about the defense of Santana, whose minus-10.1 defensive WAR (per Fangraphs) ranks 3.4 points lower than second-worst player in the MLB. “When you look at what he has done defensively, there’s no two ways about it – by WAR and by defensive runs saved, he right now is the worst defensive player in baseball.”

Drayer explained that while Smith is second-to-last with a minus-6.7 defensive WAR and Beckham is seventh-worst at minus-3.8, Smith’s past and Beckham’s future make their defense easier to digest.

“It’s a little bit scary when you look at that list, but you look at them a little bit differently. Mallex has a track record of being a decent defender, so you look at what he is right now and you say that’s fixable. You look at the metrics and you know he’s a very good athlete. You look at Tim Beckham, and right now he is essentially a placeholder because J.P. Crawford is the future shortstop of this team.”

As for Santana, the Mariners are trying to determine if he has the ability to play the outfield going forward or if he is bound to be a designated hitter for the rest of his career. And if that future is in Seattle, it will most likely have to come in left field due to All-Star Mitch Haniger having established himself in right and Daniel Vogelbach appearing to be the front-runner at DH.

Left field, however, has proven to be a difficult transition for Santana, who has played 292 of his 352 career MLB games in right.

“You brought him in to be a piece of this team hopefully for the future,” Drayer said. “When you look at the defensive numbers right now, unless there is something that drastically changes, you’re looking more at most likely a potential DH rather than an outfielder.”

You can hear Drayer’s full segment breaking down the Mariners in the player embedded in this post, or you can download the podcast at this link.

Félix Hernández is pitching well, and there’s a sign it can continue

Date Starting Pitcher
Monday, July 4 @ 3:40 pm

Mariners Roof Report

Brought to you by
Chance Drizzle
High 68° | Low 53°
Mariners are on the road.
Mariners at Padres today at 3:40pm

The John Clayton Memorial Fund

Benefitting the Multiple Sclerosis Society

The Professor's Notes

John Clayton hosts a daily video breaking down the NFL

Bump & Stacy Show

Seattle Mariners

Mariners Julio Rodriguez...
The Associated Press

Julio Rodríguez and Robbie Ray power Mariners to 2-1 win over A’s

Julio Rodríguez hit a leadoff home run and drove in another in the 6th, Robbie Ray struck out 12 and the Mariners beat the A's 2-1.
1 day ago
Mariners Kyle Lewis...
Brandon Gustafson

Mariners’ Lewis to start rehab stint and play ‘lots’ in OF, France update

The Mariners appear close to getting both Kyle Lewis and Ty France back in the lineup, according to manager Scott Servais.
1 day ago
Mariners Julio Rodriguez...
Brandon Gustafson

Has any Seattle athlete met expectations as fast as Mariners’ Rodríguez?

With Mariners OF Julio Rodríguez so quickly living up to the hype, Wyman & Bob discuss if any other Seattle athlete has done so as fast.
1 day ago
Seattle Mariners' Abraham Toro, right, has water dumped onto him by Adam Frazier, left, after Toro ...
The Associated Press

Abraham Toro’s single in 9th sends Mariners over Athletics

Abraham Toro singled home the winning run in the ninth to lift the Seattle Mariners over the Oakland Athletics 2-1 Saturday.
2 days ago
Mariners Cal Raleigh...
Brandon Gustafson

Cal Raleigh discusses his hot hitting, working with Mariners pitching, more

Starting catcher Cal Raleigh discussed plenty during a visit with Wyman & Bob, including his hot hitting and catching Mariners pitching.
2 days ago
Mariners A's...
The Associated Press

Sean Murphy’s 2 RBIs lift Oakland A’s to 3-1 win over Mariners

Sean Murphy delivered a pair of key two-out hits, including a home run, and the A's beat the Mariners 3-1 to snap a four-game losing streak.
3 days ago
Why Domingo Santana’s defense is most concerning for the Mariners