Do new claims help the case of those who think Seahawks’ Super Bowl XL loss was fixed?

Jan 31, 2019, 12:24 PM | Updated: 12:35 pm
Bill Leavy, Seahawks, Seattle Seahawks, Super Bowl XL...
Bill Leavy admitted to making officiating mistakes in Super Bowl XL. (AP)

The controversial officiating in the Rams’ NFC Championship win over New Orleans brought back some sore memories for Seahawks fans, who remember Seattle falling to the Pittsburgh Steelers 13 years prior after a series of controversial calls in Super Bowl XL.

Who are the Seahawks’ potential free agent departures?

In a 2010 interview, head referee Bill Leavy admitted to making mistakes in the game. It didn’t do much then to soothe the feelings of longtime Seattle fans, but now more than a decade (and one Super Bowl win) removed, the loss is at least easier to swallow.

A recent interview stirred up another debate about the game’s officiating, however.

Dennis Ranahan, a former oddsmaker, said in an interview with KNBR in the Bay Area that “a head official” in Super Bowl XL used to be a client of his. As Ranahan tells it, the official was looking for information through a mutual friend:

“He was looking through a guy that was a good friend of mine, and they were friends for a long time. And I said ‘Why doesn’t he call me direct?’ At the time, he was reffing college football. (My friend) says ‘Oh no, he just wants me to get the information.’ So then I’m watching that Super Bowl and thinking, ‘He’s cheating. Those guys are obviously cheating.’

“And then I’m on the radio doing a show for ESPN with Terry Cox (in 2012)… and it was before the 49ers played the Ravens in the Super Bowl. And he said, ‘Geez, we might have the biggest handle ever on a Super Bowl,’ and I went ‘Woah, wow, what was the biggest ever?’ And he said Pittsburgh-Seattle. And I went ‘Oh, geez, don’t tell me that… that seems a little fishy.'”

Fan theories claiming the game was fixed have been circulated before — and that’s to be expected when any losing team is dealt a few bad calls. But 710 ESPN Seattle’s Danny, Dave and Moore aren’t buying this one. Here are their reactions to Ranahan’s claim:

Danny O’Neil

“Now, there’s a couple different things, because everybody will react to it like ‘Oh, it’s the smoking gun’ and that would point to it. He never directly talked to Leavy. He says he goes through an intermediary. Also, Leavy apologized. He talked and admitted mistakes at a point when, several years after the fact, where if he really intentionally did that — I think they missed calls. I don’t think it was part of any underlying conspiracy. And the idea that, well, it was a crooked Super Bowl because of the outcome… man, I think people want to draw way more conclusions than there are. If Leavy had done that, why would he admit to it?”

Dave Wyman

“I don’t know. But once again, you know what’s weird about being at that game? I sat in the stands because there was an overflow in the press box… and (Brock Huard) and I were mad about the outcome, but it didn’t seem like the whole thing was dominated by penalties… but then I went home and watched it and I was mad. I was really mad. But being there, I guess it didn’t really seem that egregious as far as the penalties and everything.”

Jim Moore

“It didn’t. Danny and I were there. I remember writing my stories and just going, ‘Hey, you hear what people back in Seattle are saying about the officiating?’ You thought they were bad calls, but when you were there you didn’t sense the magnitude of it. I guess this whole thing, though, I wouldn’t believe any of it, not a shred of it, if it wasn’t for Tim Donaghy and what happened in the NBA a few years back. ”

Listen to the full episode of Danny, Dave and Moore (with audio of Ranahan’s interview) here. You can hear Danny, Dave and Moore every weekday from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m. on 710 ESPN Seattle.

Wyman & Bob

Seattle Seahawks

Brandon Gustafson

Bump: Falcons give Seahawks a chance to right wrongs from loss to 49ers

The Falcons have a similar style of offense to the 49ers, so the Seahawks get a chance to correct issues from last week, Michael Bumpus says.
2 days ago
Seahawks Pete Carroll...
Brandon Gustafson

Pete Carroll Preview: The challenges Falcons present Seahawks defense

What do the Seahawks need to do to get a Week 3 win over the Atlanta Falcons? Pete Carroll previewed the matchup on KIRO 97.3 FM.
2 days ago
Seahawks Rashaad Penny...
Stacy Rost

Rost: Seahawks haven’t been who they want to be, now have to get there

The Seahawks know the kind of team they want to be, but haven't shown it through two weeks. Stacy Rost breaks down what can change.
2 days ago
Seahawks defense...
Brandon Gustafson

K.J. Wright: Is Seahawks’ defense being as aggressive as advertised?

The Seahawks were expected to be aggressive with their new defense in 2022. K.J. Wright discusses whether that aggression is occurring.
3 days ago
Seahawks DK Metcalf...
Brent Stecker

Bump: Seahawks need DK Metcalf involved more — here’s how

While Seahawks QB Geno Smith had success finding Tyler Lockett in Week 2, he's yet to connect regularly with the other half of Seattle's WR duo.
4 days ago
Denver Broncos quarterback Russell Wilson jokes with reporters during a news conference before prac...
Associated Press

Russell Wilson off to a slow start under hesitant Hackett

Nathaniel Hackett blames his own dawdling as an unpolished play caller for Russell Wilson's slow start in Denver.
4 days ago
Do new claims help the case of those who think Seahawks’ Super Bowl XL loss was fixed?