Why GM John Schneider’s comments make Seahawks trading Earl Thomas much less likely

Apr 21, 2018, 11:56 AM | Updated: 11:57 am
Earl Thomas is entering the final year of his deal with the Seahawks. (AP)...
Earl Thomas is entering the final year of his deal with the Seahawks. (AP)

It was just over a week ago that the likelihood of the Seahawks trading Earl Thomas saw a significant jump, a result of the Dallas Cowboys making salary cap room by cutting star wide receiver Dez Bryant.

As this weekend rolled around, though, that likelihood has fallen to a percentage even lower than before.

O’Neil: Can Cowboys offer Seahawks enough to get Earl Thomas?

Seahawks general manager John Schneider said Thursday to 710 ESPN Seattle’s Danny, Dave and Moore that he’s been told Thomas won’t hold out from required offseason activities even though the All-Pro safety wasn’t present this week when involuntary workouts started at Seahawks headquarters in Renton.

“I met with his representatives (at the NFL combine) and we had great conversations, so everything seems to be fine,” Schneider said in an interview from an event in Bellevue for Ben’s Fund. “… I was informed that he would not hold out. That that was not his intention, according to his representation.”

The next day, each member of Danny, Dave and Moore explained how they interpreted Schneider’s comments and why they now think a trade of Thomas, who is entering the final year of his contract and has publicly stated his desire to sign a contract extension before the 2018 season, is much less likely than previously thought.

Here’s what Danny O’Neil, Dave Wyman and Jim Moore said about the situation.

Danny O’Neil

• “I think a trade is very unlikely given what Schneider said (Thursday), the fact that they’re not feeling forced into that. Now, to be the devil’s advocate, if you were gonna trade him, you would not want to appear at the end of a sharp blade. You would not want people to think that Earl’s told you he’s not going to show up, because that reduces whatever leverage you think you might have. … But I’ve never known John Schneider to be someone who is manipulative or misleading in what he says. He’s a guy that (instead) will go quiet and will not necessarily talk or respond to requests.”

• “Right now is the posturing side of the negotiations on both sides. … The fact that the two sides haven’t dug their heels in, I think is very positive.”

• “My ideal situation for the Seahawks and Earl Thomas: him to play this final year of his contract and then you revisit it at the end of the year. That you don’t leverage anything more into the future, to try and keep him at the stage your team is at, at the age he’s at, and he’s still getting a good salary. And if he’s willing to play for that, absolutely be able to revisit this 12 months from now.”

Dave Wyman

• “(Schneider) said that very confidently. I don’t think he would have said something like that if he didn’t have a really good idea that that’s what going to happen. … I’ve gotten to be pretty good friends with him, and I never hear from him during this time of year. … He’s one of those guys that, he keeps things pretty secret. … I just think that says a lot. That eased my fears about Earl Thomas quite a bit.”

• “It sounds like both sides really trust each other, because if you’re John Schneider, it would probably make you look pretty bad if (Thomas) did hold out after you just said that.”

Jim Moore

• “It sounded like Earl’s representation knows where the Seahawks stand. Just the way it was worded led me to believe that, ‘OK, this is where the Seahawks are, this is how much they want to give you in an extension, Earl. If you like it, great, but we’re probably not going to move too far off of this number that we’ve given you.’ … Just based on the fact that he’s not going to hold out, maybe it’s closer to that $13 million number (that Eric Berry, the highest-paid safety in the NFL, makes per year).”

• “Now with this news it sounds to me like it’s 10 or 20 percent that they’re gonna trade him.”

You can hear the full segment in this podcast of Danny, Dave and Moore’s show Friday. To hear Schneider’s interview from Thursday’s show, click here.

SI’s Greg Bishop details what went into ‘dismantling’ of the Seahawks

Wyman & Bob

Bump & Stacy Show

Wyman and Bob

Mariners Justin Upton...
Brent Stecker

Mariners’ Justin Upton, ex-Angel, shares his take on beef between rivals

No one on the field Sunday had quite the same perspective as Mariners outfielder Justin Upton, who shared his thoughts with Wyman and Bob.
3 days ago
mariners angels...
Brent Stecker

Mariners Breakdown: Who looks best, worst following Angels brawl

There's a lot to discuss after the Mariners threw down with the Angels on Sunday. Bob Stelton of Wyman and Bob makes sense of it all.
3 days ago
Mariners Paul Sewald...
Brent Stecker

Since joining Mariners, Paul Sewald has taken ‘180-degree turn’

Paul Sewald explained Friday with Wyman and Bob what the difference has been for him with the Mariners compared to his time with the Mets.
4 days ago
Mariners Cal Raleigh...
Brent Stecker

Blowers: Mariners’ Cal Raleigh seeing results because of one difference

Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh is doing one thing at the plate that is making all the difference, according to Mike Blowers.
8 days ago
Mariners Ty France...
Brent Stecker

Mariners Breakdown: Where does blame belong for season’s stumbles?

In a new edition of Bob's Baseball Breakdown, Seattle Sports' Bob Stelton doesn't hold back on the Mariners' disappointing season thus far.
10 days ago
Seahawks DK Metcalf...
Mike Lefko

Inside the numbers of a potential Seahawks-DK Metcalf extension

What could be preventing the Seahawks and DK Metcalf from agreeing on a new deal? Mike Lefko looks at what the numbers could be.
10 days ago
Why GM John Schneider’s comments make Seahawks trading Earl Thomas much less likely