Opinion: Replacement refs “tarnishing” NFL

Sep 18, 2012, 10:24 AM | Updated: 10:31 am

“This is now the on field product in the NFL that is being tarnished and embarrassed,” said Mike Salk about the replacement referees. (AP image)

When a replacement referee marked off a five yard penalty 11 yards down field in Monday night’s NFL game, it was just the latest in a series of gaffes marring the first two weeks of the season. And Brock and Salk are among the scores of critics calling on NFL commissioner Roger Goodell to bring the lockout to an end.

“What a travesty that was to watch. Roger Goodell should be ashamed,” said co-host Mike Salk.

Among the issues are pay, staffing levels and pension, with the NFL seeking to freeze retirement funding for referees. With officials refusing to buy off on the cut backs, the league has locked them out and brought in mostly high school and junior college referees in their place. The result has been numerous blown calls, cheap shots and interminable delays as the replacements struggle to keep the games in check.

“You’re watching substitute teachers not being able to officiate, not being able to dictate, not being able to communicate what you’re doing,” said co-host Brock Huard.

“This is now the on field product in the NFL that is being tarnished and embarrassed,” said Salk. “And when you’re looking through the Twitter feed last night and you see 10, 12 Tweets in a row from people you respect from Peter King, from Adam Schefter from Darren Rovell, from former players from people around the country, from other talk show hosts from fans and every one of them is saying alright enough’s enough Roger, let your ego go and just get over it.”

While the NFL claims the replacement referees are doing an acceptable job and have shown improvement, Brock and Salk said it’s clear they are simply not up to the task.

“These are single A, minor league players that are getting thrown into the bigs, and they can’t do it. They can’t administrate the rules. And it is affecting your product,” said Huard.

While there were no overwhelmingly bad calls that impacted either of the Seahawks first two games, Salk argues they’ve been affected indirectly, saying rival Arizona could easily be 1-1 if not for a “very bad call” against Rob Gronkowski that negated a go ahead touchdown for the Patriots.

“There’s no time to wait for the replacements to improve. It’s embarrassing now,” said Salk.

Brock and Salk podcast

Brock and Salk

Seahawks Pete Carroll...
Brent Stecker

ESPN’s Riddick thinks Seahawks’ Carroll knew all along they were good

ESPN analyst and former NFL safety Louis Riddick was around the Seahawks in the preseason, and he saw a "twinkle in the eye" of Pete Carroll at the time.
20 hours ago
Seahawks Tariq Woolen...
Brandon Gustafson

Seahawks’ Carroll: Tariq Woolen has ‘legitimate chance’ to be dominant

Seahawks rookie CB Tariq Woolen came away with his sixth interception on Sunday. Pete Carroll discussed Woolen's play and sky-high potential.
20 hours ago
Mariners offseason Tyler O'Neill...
Mike Salk

Salk: 10 options for the Mariners to complete their outfield

The Mariners have made three notable additions, and the fourth should be an outfielder. Mike Salk breaks down who the targets could be.
2 days ago
Seahawks Geno Smith...
Brandon Gustafson

Carroll: Importance of Seahawks’ win over Rams, Geno’s big finish

On the latest Pete Carroll Show, the Seahawks coach discussed his team's win over the Rams and the play and mentality of QB Geno Smith.
2 days ago
UW Huskies Michael Penix Jr...
Brandon Gustafson

Huard: Why UW Huskies QB Michael Penix Jr. is returning for 1 more year

UW Huskies QB Michael Penix Jr. surprised many with the news he's returning to school for 2023. Brock Huard explains why that's happening.
2 days ago
Seahawks Kenneth Walker III...
Brent Stecker

Seahawks Injuries: Carroll on Kenneth Walker III, banged-up RBs

Seahawks coach Pete Carroll provided updates on three of Seattle's banged-up running backs during his weekly Monday morning show on Seattle Sports.
2 days ago
Opinion: Replacement refs “tarnishing” NFL