Is 13 too young for tackle football?

Oct 30, 2012, 3:26 PM | Updated: Nov 1, 2012, 6:19 am


There's a battle brewing over how old kids should have to be to play sports like football, hockey and soccer. (AP Photo/file)

(AP Photo/file)

At what age is it safe for kids to play tackle football or body check in hockey?

There’s a battle brewing in Switzerland over that question. A world-renowned concussion expert says we should set an age limit on letting kids participate, but a local doctor thinks that is a terrible idea.

Dr. Robert Cantu is a professor of Neurosurgey at the Boston University School of Medicine. He is one of the featured speakers at the 4th Annual International Consensus Conference on Concussion at the FIFA Headquarters in Zurich.

Dr. Cantu is proposing that children under the age of 14 should not be allowed to take part in the more dangerous aspects of sports like football, hockey and soccer.

“The scientific evidence that age 14 is the right age, is a bit of a stretch,” counters Dr. Stan Herring, Director of Sports and Orthopedic Medicine at the UW Medical Center.

Dr. Herring is also a team physician for the Seahawks and the Mariners. He is attending the conference in Switzerland, in part, to counter Dr. Cantu’s recommendation.

He says he hasn’t seen any evidence that 14-year-olds are better able to handle the damage done by a concussion than are kids who are 12 or 13. Herring also worries an age limit would give parents a false sense of security.

“I don’t want parents to allow their parents to participate in sports thinking that all safety measures have been met. We just don’t know,” says Herring.

Washington passed the ground breaking Lystedt Law on youth concussions in 2009. It has now been copied by 40 other states, and Herring argues this is a better approach. Herring will be presenting Lystedt at the conference in Zurich.

The law includes specific guidelines about how teams have to treat kids who may have suffered a concussion during a practice or a game. It also requires parents and athletes to be given information ahead of time about how to spot the injury.

“Sports is really pretty safe for most kids, and even most concussions are safe,” Herring says. “The great majority of people who suffer concussions get better, but not everyone does.”

At the end of the conference, the experts will try to find consensus. They will be writing a paper to detail what they believe are the best practices for avoiding concussion. Herring says it’s important because their recommendation will likely be a reference for sports organizations around the world.

Other Sports

Associated Press

Ex-Packer Guion gets 1 year for domestic violence assault

GREEN BAY, Wis. (AP) — Former Green Bay Packers defensive tackle Letroy Guion was sentenced to one year in jail after pleading no contest in a domestic violence assault at his home last fall. Brown County Circuit Court Judge Thomas Walsh also ordered Guion on Tuesday to serve three years’ probation and complete a domestic […]

1 year ago

Joe Jarzynka...

Associated Press

Durant eager for Suns debut vs. Hornets after knee injury

CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — Kevin Durant has been through quite a bit during his 15-year NBA career — but joining a new team midway through the season is a new one for the 13-time All-Star. The 34-year-old Durant doesn’t seem all that worried. Durant makes his highly anticipated Phoenix Suns debut on Wednesday night against […]

1 year ago

FILE - Miami Dolphins head coach Brian Flores stands on the sideline during the second half of an N...

Associated Press

Judge: NFL coach can press discrimination claims in court

NEW YORK (AP) — NFL Coach Brian Flores can pursue some of his discrimination claims against the league and its teams in court rather than through arbitration, a judge ruled Wednesday. The written decision by Judge Valerie Caproni in Manhattan was issued months after lawyers for the league tried to get the lawsuit moved to […]

1 year ago

Chicago Blackhawks goaltender Alex Stalock cools off in the first period during an NHL hockey game ...

Associated Press

Kane trade reinforces hard reality of Blackhawks rebuild

CHICAGO (AP) — After days of speculation, the harsh reality of the Chicago Blackhawks’ situation was reinforced by one move in a flurry of transactions ahead of the NHL trade deadline. Showtime is over, at least in Chicago, and a seemingly bright future is, well, way off in the distance. The reverberations of Chicago’s decision […]

1 year ago

FILE -  Yves Jean-Bart, president of the Haitian Football Federation, wearing a protective face mas...

Associated Press

Disgraced ex-Haitian soccer president announces he’s back

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti (AP) — Haiti’s former soccer federation president whose lifetime ban from sport over sexual abuse allegations was overturned last month announced Wednesday that he is reclaiming his position. Yves Jean-Bart’s defiant announcement could lead to a standoff with FIFA, which already has appointed an emergency management committee to lead the Haitian Football Association […]

1 year ago

FILE - Green Bay Packers' Aaron Rodgers walks off the field after an NFL football game against the ...

Associated Press

Rodgers says decision on future will come ‘soon enough’

GREEN BAY, Wis. (AP) — Aaron Rodgers says he will make a decision on his future “soon enough” as the four-time MVP quarterback ponders whether to play next season and if his future remains with the Green Bay Packers. Rodgers, 39, discussed his future while speaking on an episode of the “Aubrey Marcus Podcast” that […]

1 year ago

Is 13 too young for tackle football?