Judge rules against longshore union, allowing Seattle arena plan to progress

Feb 22, 2013, 2:39 PM | Updated: Feb 23, 2013, 7:34 am
A King County Judge has ruled against a legal challenge to a proposed new Seattle arena, clearing a...
A King County Judge has ruled against a legal challenge to a proposed new Seattle arena, clearing a major hurdle in the deal between investor Chris Hansen, Seattle and King County. (AP image)
(AP image)

A King County Judge has ruled against a legal challenge to a proposed new Seattle arena, clearing a major hurdle in the deal between investor Chris Hansen, Seattle and King County.

King County Superior Court Judge Douglass North ruled moments after hearing arguments from the International Longshore and Warehouse Union and lawyers for Hansen, Seattle and King County.

The union argued unsuccessfully an environmental review should have preceded any agreement, and local officials violated state law by going ahead with the agreement anyway.

The union also argued adding a third stadium to the area south of downtown would choke freight traffic and cost jobs.

The “memorandum of understanding” signed last year setting out the parameters of a deal to build the $490 million arena created irreversible momentum toward construction, and therefore the environmental study was required, union attorney David Mann said in asking the judge to invalidate the agreement.

“This case is not about whether the Sonics should or are returning to Seattle,” Mann said. “What the case is about is whether the city council, the mayor, the county council and executive went too far.”

The NBA’s Supersonics played in Seattle from 1967 to 2008 before its new owners moved the team to Oklahoma City and renamed it the Thunder. Outside court, the director of “Sonicsgate,” Jason Reed expressed relief over the ruling adding it should calm any fears NBA owners have about approving the sale of the Sacramento Kings.

Hansen’s group, which includes Microsoft Chief Executive Steve Ballmer, has reached a deal to buy the Kings from the Maloof family and move the team to Seattle, but it still needs approval from the NBA. Sacramento Mayor Kevin Johnson has been trying to put together a rival investment group to keep the team.

The judge expressed skepticism about the union’s arguments, noting – as lawyers for Hansen, Seattle and King County did – that the agreement does not actually commit the city and county to building an arena south of downtown, and that an environmental review will be done before any such commitment is made. State law requires environmental reviews “before an agency commits to a particular course of action.”

“How does it bind them into going forward with a SoDo arena?” North asked.

“There is no authority for the city to approve an alternative location,” Mann responded.

Another lawyer for the union, Peter Goldman, described the promise of a future environmental review as a “sham,” saying that by the time a review is completed, the Sonics could be back in Seattle, playing at KeyArena in anticipation of a new arena being built. No city government is going to reject the building of the arena in SoDo at that point, he argued.

“We’re still going to work the process very carefully as the E.I.S. unfolds,” said Mann. “We’re going to be very involved with explaining, making sure that the E.I.S. fully documents traffic impacts, transportation impacts, impacts to the port, impacts to these working families.” But Mann said the union had not decided if it will appeal the judge’s ruling.
An assistant Seattle city attorney said the city has authority under state law to pick other arena sites if necessary.

The Associated Press contributed to this report


Memphis Grizzlies' Kennedy Chandler shoots between Milwaukee Bucks' Grayson Allen snd Sandro Mamuke...
Associated Press

Rookies, late rally lead Grizzlies over Bucks 107-102

MILWAUKEE (AP) — Rookie David Roddy scored 18 points, two-way signee Kenny Lofton Jr. added 17 and the Memphis Grizzlies used a late run to beat the Milwaukee Bucks 107-102 on Saturday night in the opening preseason game for both teams. Many of the star players for both teams didn’t play. Milwaukee All-Star Giannis Antetokounmpo, […]
1 day ago
Gold medalists the United States hold their trophy aloft as they celebrate on the podium after defe...
Associated Press

US women’s basketball dominates on international stage

SYDNEY (AP) — A’ja Wilson and Breanna Stewart are keenly aware of the legacy of success they are part of with the U.S. women’s basketball team. They don’t plan on letting the incredible run end any time soon. “I don’t think we’re showing signs of stopping, that’s for sure,” Stewart said. “We have a lot […]
2 days ago
Gold medalists the United States hold their trophy as they celebrate on the podium after defeating ...
Associated Press

US women win fourth straight gold at World Cup, top China

SYDNEY (AP) — The names on the U.S. team have changed, the Americans’ dominance has not. A’ja Wilson scored 19 points, Kelsey Plum added 17 and the United States beat China 83-61 on Saturday to win its fourth consecutive gold medal at the women’s basketball World Cup. “It feels great,” said Wilson, who was selected […]
2 days ago
Australian players cheer from the bench during their bronze medal game against Canada at the women'...
Associated Press

Australia wins bronze, Lauren Jackson scores 30 in finale

SYDNEY (AP) — Lauren Jackson admitted she couldn’t have imagined a better ending to her Hall of Fame career. Jackson willed Australia to a win in the bronze medal game at basketball’s World Cup, scoring 30 points to lead the Opals to a 95-65 win over Canada on Saturday. “I could have never dreamed of […]
2 days ago
FILE - Boston Celtics forward Jayson Tatum (0) drives against Brooklyn Nets forward Blake Griffin (...
Associated Press

AP source: Celtics agree to terms with big man Blake Griffin

BOSTON (AP) — Veteran big man Blake Griffin has agreed to a contract with the Boston Celtics, a person familiar with the deal told The Associated Press on Friday. The person confirmed the move to the AP on the condition of anonymity because the deal had not been announced. It was first reported by ESPN. […]
3 days ago
Golden State Warriors' James Wiseman, center, dunks against Washington Wizards during their preseas...
Associated Press

Wiseman stars as Warriors, Wizards open preseason in Tokyo

TOKYO (AP) — James Wiseman, who missed all of last season while rehabilitating after a knee injury, scored 20 points Friday as the defending champion Golden State Warriors defeated the Washington Wizards 96-87 to open the NBA preseason. Wiseman played 24 minutes, connecting on eight of 11 shots, while adding nine rebounds and one block […]
3 days ago
Judge rules against longshore union, allowing Seattle arena plan to progress