Geno Smith takes blame, but plenty of reasons Seahawks faltered

Oct 17, 2023, 8:10 AM | Updated: 11:05 am

Seattle Seahawks Geno Smith...

Seattle Seahawks QB Geno Smith slides during an Oct. 15, 2023 game at Cincinnati. (Dylan Buell/Getty Images)

(Dylan Buell/Getty Images)

RENTON, Wash. (AP) — If something doesn’t go right, Seattle Seahawks quarterback Geno Smith is usually quick to take the blame — even if he’s not completely at fault.

That was the case again Sunday after the Seahawks’ frustrating 17-13 loss at Cincinnati where Smith had far from his best game.

Rost: What issues for Seattle Seahawks’ offense need to be fixed?

Despite throwing for 323 yards, Smith tossed two interceptions, missed a couple of big play opportunities and at times appeared hesitant to throw. He also took a costly sack in the fourth quarter that turned first-and-goal at the Cincinnati 7 into second-and-goal at the 19, one of four trips to the red zone where Seattle failed to come away with points and ultimately proved the difference.

“I felt like the guys deserved to win today. Obviously, I didn’t do my best job today to get that done,” Smith said. “So those are things I put on myself, I lay right on my feet right, on my shoulders and I look forward to the next opportunity.”

Smith needed to be better in some critical moments, but he didn’t need to shoulder all the blame for this loss. Seattle’s makeshift offensive line finally showed leaks after somehow holding together the past few weeks with several starters out. One of Smith’s interceptions was a miscommunication with DK Metcalf. And Seattle’s play calling could have put Smith in a better position for some of those red zone trips that came up empty.

“We had so many ways to win in that football game and so many ways to score and opportunities that got squandered,” Seattle coach Pete Carroll said. “But there was just a lot of positives moving forward.”


Seattle defensive coordinator Clint Hurtt deserves recognition for the adjustments made in the second half that stifled Cincinnati’s offense. The Bengals were held to three points, 52 total yards and four first downs in the second half by Seattle. The three points came after a turnover and a drive during which Cincinnati gained zero yards.

Cincinnati finished with 214 total yards, the second straight opponent Seattle has held under 250 yards of offense. The last time Seattle did that was Weeks 16 and 17 in 2015.

The focus this offseason was on improving the run defense and Seattle certainly has done that. The Bengals rushed for 46 yards and averaged 3.1 yards per rush. But the overall performance has to be an encouraging sign moving forward.


The offensive line was a mess in the second half and led to some of the problems Smith faced. Smith had been hit a total of 12 times during Seattle’s three-game win streak. He was hit 13 times by the Bengals. The protection just wasn’t there the way it needed to be, even with the return of left tackle Charles Cross after missing the previous three games with a toe injury.

Getting guard Damien Lewis back this week from an ankle injury would help the interior of the line.


Jamal Adams made it through his first full game since Week 12 of the 2021 season. And on the surface he appeared to play well. Adams had four tackles, one tackle for loss and one QB hit, and played 85% of the defensive snaps.

His return in Week 4 from a torn quadriceps tendon that cost him more than a year lasted all of nine plays before suffering a concussion. Sunday was a much more satisfying return.

“That was the goal. I was just taking it one quarter at a time,” Adams said. “Obviously, I was on a little rep count. That was killing me to be on the sideline, but I understood the routine and I understood the plan. I feel great.”


Metcalf continues to have an issue with committing undisciplined penalties. Metcalf was flagged for unnecessary roughness in the second quarter, getting penalized some 30 yards away from where the play took place. Metcalf also had a 15-yard taunting penalty in Week 1 and has five 15-yard penalties for unsportsmanlike conduct, unnecessary roughness or taunting in the past two seasons.


Seattle didn’t appear to pick up any significant new injuries coming out of the loss, although the health of the offensive line will be closely watched. The Seahawks don’t expect starting right tackle Abraham Lucas to be ready to return this week even though he’s eligible to come off injured reserve.


4 — Seattle has lost its last four games following its bye week. Last year, it was a 40-34 overtime loss at home to Las Vegas. In 2021, the Seahawks lost 17-0 at Green Bay, and in 2020 it was a 37-34 overtime loss at Arizona. The last time Seattle won out of the bye was 2019 when it beat Philadelphia 17-9.


The Seahawks will face an NFC West opponent for the first time since Week 1 when they host Arizona on Sunday. The Seahawks have won three straight in the series, but is just 2-2 in the past four meetings in Seattle.

More on the Seattle Seahawks

Seahawks’ Carroll: What went right on defense, wrong on offense
Seattle Sports’ Instant Reaction: What happened in Hawks’ loss to Bengals?
Seahawks lament wasted chances in red zone in loss to Bengals
Seahawks’ offense spoils big day by defense in loss to Bengals
The Big Plays: Video highlights from Seattle Seahawks’ loss in Cincy

Seattle Seahawks

Seattle Seahawks Riq Woolen OTAs 2024...

Stacy Rost

Rost: Ranking Seahawks players who are under the most pressure

Even though expectations may be lower for the Seattle Seahawks under first-year head coach Mike Macdonald, some players have a lot of pressure on them for 2024.

21 hours ago

Seattle Seahawks Abraham Lucas...

Brent Stecker

Seahawks place 7 on PUP list prior to training camp

The Seattle Seahawks announced seven players Thursday that have been placed on the physically unable to perform (PUP) list ahead of training camp next week.

2 days ago

Seattle Seahawks Mike Macdonald...

Maura Dooley

What NFL insiders say about 3 big Seattle Seahawks questions

Still trying to figure out what the Seattle Seahawks will look like under coach Mike Macdonald? Find out what three NFL insiders have said.

2 days ago

Seattle Seahawks WR UFL Marcus Simms...

Brent Stecker

What are the Seahawks getting in latest wide receiver addition?

The Seattle Seahawks are reportedly adding another standout from the UFL spring football league. Brock Huard details WR Marcus Simms.

3 days ago

Seattle Seahawks 49ers Brandon Aiyuk...

Amiliano Fragoso, SacTown Sports

NFC West Check-In: 49ers star Aiyuk reportedly requests trade

With the clock getting nearer and nearer to a new NFL season, Brandon Aiyuk appears to be fed up with waiting on the San Francisco 49ers to meet his price.

4 days ago

NFL training camp Russell Wilson Pittsburgh Steelers...

Rob Maaddi

NFL Training Camps: Top storylines and more as rookies report

The short summer vacation is over for NFL players with the arrival of training camps. It’s time to begin the journey to Super Bowl 59.

5 days ago

Geno Smith takes blame, but plenty of reasons Seahawks faltered