World Series viewing turning into a participation sport

Nov 4, 2022, 1:05 AM | Updated: 1:06 pm
Philadelphia Phillies' Bryce Harper rounds the bases after a two-run home run hit off Houston Astro...

Philadelphia Phillies' Bryce Harper rounds the bases after a two-run home run hit off Houston Astros starting pitcher Lance McCullers Jr. during the first inning in Game 3 of baseball's World Series between the Houston Astros and the Philadelphia Phillies on Tuesday, Nov. 1, 2022, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip)

(AP Photo/David J. Phillip)

Houston’s Lance McCullers Jr. says he wasn’t tipping pitches during his Game 3 five-homer meltdown in the World Series. The internet disagreed.

Advantage, internet.

We may never know exactly what Phillies slugger Bryce Harper told Alec Bohm when he called the third baseman back toward the dugout and whispered a few words in his ear, but internet sleuths were happy to fill the void, with ‘whodunit-style’ videos popping up immediately. They dissected everything from McCullers’ leg kick, to the direction his feet were pointing, to where he was holding his glove during his delivery.

(Example: McCullers’ leg is two millimeters higher that it was on the previous pitch. That’s gotta be a changeup!)

Welcome to sports viewing in 2022.

That’s not to say the new world of enjoying sports on the couch is necessarily bad, or even all that new. It’s just become even more of a participation event. Professional golf has gone through its own mini-crises over the past decade because TV viewers call in potential rules violations that PGA officials didn’t catch.

Legal online live-betting — available in a large chunk of the U.S. — has created another incentive to decipher any in-game trends. Bettors can wager on anything from the speed of the next pitch, to the outcome of the next at-bat, to the amount of pitches thrown in an inning.

The lulls and relatively slow pace of both golf and baseball make them ripe targets for online, real-time detective work. The McCullers fiasco wasn’t even the first controversial case in this year’s World Series. In Game 2, the internet noticed that Astros starter Framber Valdez was making odd hand motions, rubbing his left thumb across his right hand, then rubbing the ball between pitches.

How did the Phillies find out the potential problem?

I’ll give you one guess.

“Yeah, we did … it’s all over Twitter,” Phillies manager Rob Thomson said. “The umpires check these guys after almost every inning, and if there’s something going on, MLB will take care of it.”

Valdez made a good point: If he was cheating, he certainly wasn’t being very careful.

“I do it out in the open,” Valdez said via a translator. “But it’s all tendencies I do. I do it throughout the game. Maybe distract the hitter a little bit from what I’m doing. Like maybe look at me, rubbing different things, and nothing about the pitch that I’m going to throw. I’ve been doing it all season.”

It makes sense that the Astros — who now have a 3-2 lead as the World Series moves back to Houston — would be a highly sought target for baseball’s internet police. The franchise’s video sign-stealing scandal from 2017 still lingers, even though only five players remain on the team from that roster.

In retrospect, it’s kind of hard to believe those same online sheriffs didn’t catch those 2017 Astros in real time. Banging trash cans usually makes a lot of noise.

The evolution of sports viewing makes for some interesting thought exercises when it comes to baseball’s storied history. Can you imagine Twitter existing in 1985? Umpire Don Denkinger’s call at first base in Game 6, helping the Royals beat the Cardinals, might have broken the internet.

What about potential fan-angle phone videos of the Steve Bartman incident in 2003, when the Cubs fan famously got in the way of Moises Alou when he tried to make a catch near the wall in the NLCS? Or in 1996, when young fan Jeffrey Maier appeared to interfere with a fly ball that was ruled a homer for Yankees star Derek Jeter?

Surely, Twitter would have taken those events in stride. (Insert eye roll emoji.)

As for McCullers, it was never definitively proven he was tipping his pitches when he gave up his five homers to the Phillies in Game 3. Even one of the sport’s most respected internet sleuths — JomboyMedia — couldn’t find a smoking gun.

“Guys are always looking for something, always looking to see if they’re tipping their pitches,” Astros manager Dusty Baker said. “We didn’t see anything.”

But once the internet has decided something, it’s hard to change its mind.

“I got whooped. End of story,” McCullers said in the aftermath of Game 3. “This has nothing to do with tipping.”


AP Baseball Writer Ronald Blum and AP Sports Writer Kristie Rieken contributed to this report.


AP MLB: and

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


FILE -  New York Yankees' Aaron Judge gestures as he runs the bases after hitting a solo home run, ...
Associated Press

AP source: Aaron Judge, Yankees reach $360M, 9-year deal

SAN DIEGO (AP) — Aaron Judge has agreed to return to the New York Yankees on a $360 million, nine-year contract, according to a person familiar with the deal. The person spoke to The Associated Press on Wednesday because the deal had not been announced. Judge will earn $40 million per season, the highest average […]
1 day ago
Belgium's Eden Hazard reacts at the end of the World Cup group F soccer match between Croatia and B...
Associated Press

Belgium forward Hazard retires from international soccer

BRUSSELS (AP) — Belgium forward Eden Hazard retired from international soccer on Wednesday, nearly a week after his country’s aging generation of players was eliminated from the World Cup. The 31-year-old winger made his debut with the national team in 2008 at the age of 17. He made 126 appearances and scored 33 goals. “A […]
1 day ago
Orlando Magic's Paolo Banchero (5) looks to get around Milwaukee Bucks' Jrue Holiday, left, during ...
Associated Press

Paolo’s Diary: Magic rookie says he’s doing much learning

(EDITOR’S NOTE — Orlando Magic rookie and No. 1 overall draft pick Paolo Banchero is doing a periodic diary with The Associated Press this season to chronicle his first year in the NBA. This is his second installment, the first since the regular season started. The Magic are an NBA-worst 5-20 through the first 25 […]
1 day ago
Brazil's Neymar celebrates scoring his side's second goal during the World Cup round of 16 soccer m...
Associated Press

World Cup Viewer’s Guide: Quarterfinalists bid for title

DOHA, Qatar (AP) — After non-stop soccer for the past two weeks, the World Cup is taking a small break. There will be two days of rest before the quarterfinals start in Qatar with at least one surprising team still in contention to win soccer’s biggest prize. Morocco produced the latest upset in a tournament […]
1 day ago
Spain's players react after the penalty shootout at the World Cup round of 16 soccer match between ...
Associated Press

Young Spain squad and its ‘tiki-taka’ stumble at World Cup

DOHA, Qatar (AP) — Spain lost to Morocco 3-0 in a penalty shootout in the round of 16 at the World Cup on Tuesday, failing to make it to the quarterfinals for the third straight time since winning its last world title in South Africa in 2010. La Roja also lost in a shootout in […]
1 day ago
Portugal's Cristiano Ronaldo walks during the World Cup round of 16 soccer match between Portugal a...
Associated Press

Ronaldo loses Portugal spot to sully World Cup journey

DOHA, Qatar (AP) — So, the dream is still alive for Cristiano Ronaldo. Soccer’s most prolific modern-day scorer might yet, at the age of 37 and probably playing in his last World Cup, claim the one major title to elude him in a career like no other. It didn’t quite feel that way, though, as […]
1 day ago
World Series viewing turning into a participation sport