IOC transgender guidelines hailed but questions remain

Nov 18, 2021, 7:32 AM | Updated: 9:34 pm
Washington Spirit forward Ashley Hatch, left, heads the ball in front of OL Reign midfielder Quinn ...

Washington Spirit forward Ashley Hatch, left, heads the ball in front of OL Reign midfielder Quinn in the second half in the semifinals of the NWSL soccer playoffs Sunday, Nov. 14, 2021, in Tacoma, Wash. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

(AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

WELLINGTON, New Zealand (AP) — New International Olympic Committee guidelines to sports bodies on transgender participation have been hailed as groundbreaking for reversing assumptions that trans women enjoy automatic advantages in female sports.

But several experts say the framework of 10 principles, released by the IOC this week, likely can still be used to restrict the eligibility of trans women.

The IOC said the framework which updates 2015 guidelines introduces a more evidence-based approach to eligibility which requires proof based on peer-reviewed research a trans athlete might have a competitive advantage.

It acknowledges “the central role that eligibility criteria play in ensuring fairness, particularly in high-level organized sport” among women.

The framework “recognizes both the need to ensure that everyone, irrespective of their gender identity or sex variations, can practice sport in a safe, harassment-free environment” and “the interest of everyone … to participate in fair competitions where no participant has an unfair and disproportionate advantage over the rest.”

The new guidelines are not legally binding and the IOC says it remains “within the remit of each sport and its governing body to determine how an athlete may be at a disproportionate advantage compared with their peers.”

“The IOC is therefore not in a position to issue regulations that define eligibility criteria for every sport, discipline or event across the very different national jurisdictions and sport systems.”

The new guidelines have been applauded by prominent trans athlete Quinn, who uses only one name and who won an Olympic gold medal with the Canada women’s soccer team in July, becoming the first openly transgender or non-binary athlete to compete at an Olympic games.

In a statement Quinn said sports policy often “does not reflect the lived experience of marginalized athletes and that’s especially true when it comes to transgender athletes and athletes with sex variations.

“This new IOC framework is groundbreaking in the way that it reflects what we know to be true — that athletes like me and my peers participate in sports without any inherent advantage, and that our humanity deserves to be respected.”

Dr. Jami Taylor, a political science professor at the University of Toledo, Ohio and expert on LGBTQ politics, said barriers to transgender participation likely will remain.

“Many observers thought the IOC would crack down on transgender participation given the uproar over (New Zealand transgender weightlifter) Laurel Hubbard’s participation in the recent summer Olympics,” Taylor said. “At least at first glance the new guidelines for the federations start from a place of transgender inclusion.”

Taylor told The Associated Press she was “shocked a little” at the relaxation evident in the new IOC approach.

“However, the guidelines are not binding. They also provide a roadmap to restrict eligibility by relying on peer reviewed research in standard six,” she said. Standard six says any restrictions on eligibility should be based on robust and peer-reviewed research.

“As noted in standard six, there is a pathway to restrict trans women from competition. I fully expect that to be utilized,” Dr. Taylor said.

She said “sport by sport standards really do seem to be the way to go. For instance, boxing and gymnastics are different sports that rely on different attributes and skills. There are also some risk factors.”

Taylor has cited the work of Joanna Harper, visiting fellow for transgender athletic performance at England’s Loughborough University.

Harper, who is a transgender woman and competitive athlete, told The Guardian that while she welcomed the emphasis on inclusion, playing down competitive advantages is concerning.

“Transgender women are on average, taller, bigger and stronger than cis women and these are advantages in many sports,” she said. “It is also unreasonable to ask the sports federations to have robust and peer reviewed research before placing restrictions on trans athletes in elite sport. Such research will take years if not decades.”

The IOC has acknowledged the difficulty of balancing inclusiveness with competitive advantage and risk.

Spokesman Christian Klaue said on Tuesday “we have not found the solution to this big question. Clearly this is a topic that will be with us for a long time.”


More AP Olympics: and

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Relatives stand nearby as survivors of Saturday's soccer riots are treated at a hospital in Malang,...
Associated Press

Relatives mourn those crushed at Indonesia soccer match

JEMBER, Indonesia (AP) — Families and friends of some of the 125 people who died in a deadly crush after an Indonesia soccer match wailed in grief as the bodies of the victims were returned home Monday. Seventeen children were among the dead. The distraught family members were struggling to comprehend the sudden loss of […]
23 hours ago
Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Tom Brady (12) throws a pass during the second half of an NFL foot...
Associated Press

Tom Brady gets Bucs offense going, defense struggles

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) — Tom Brady looked more like himself, carrying Tampa Bay’s offense with his arm. Only problem for the Buccaneers was the defense couldn’t stop Patrick Mahomes and the rest of Kansas City’s offense. “Our red zone defense was poor. Our run defense was poor. Our pass defense was poor. Our third-down efficiency […]
23 hours ago
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15) celebrates a touchdown during the first half of...
Associated Press

Mahomes throws for 3 TDs, Chiefs overwhelm Buccaneers 41-31

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) — Patrick Mahomes had all the answers for solving Tampa Bay’s stingy defense, winning his latest matchup against Tom Brady in the stadium where the seven-time Super Bowl winner dealt him one of his most disappointing losses. Mahomes threw for 249 yards and three touchdowns, including an electrifying jump pass to Clyde […]
23 hours ago
New York Mets manager Buck Showalter left, relieves starting pitcher Chris Bassitt center, in the t...
Associated Press

Braves sweep Mets, take 2-game lead in East with 3 remaining

ATLANTA (AP) — Matt Olson knew the Atlanta Braves were too talented to stay in a season-long slump. That’s why no one panicked when the New York Mets’ division lead swelled to double digits in May. Now the Braves are on the cusp of another NL East title. “It’s a clubhouse full of guys who […]
23 hours ago
Relatives stand nearby as survivors of Saturday's soccer riots are treated at a hospital in Malang,...
Associated Press

Stadium tragedy exposes Indonesia’s troubled soccer history

SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — Gaining the right to host next year’s Under-20 World Cup was a major milestone in Indonesia’s soccer development, raising hopes that a successful tournament would turn around long-standing problems that have blighted the sport in this country of 277 million people. The death of at least 125 people at a […]
23 hours ago
New York Yankees' Aaron Judge reacts after striking out during the seventh inning of a baseball gam...
Associated Press

Yankees star Judge tries again for AL-record 62nd home run

A look at Aaron Judge of the New York Yankees as he approaches major home run milestones: Season HR Total: 61 Sunday’s Game: Struck out three times while going 0 for 3 with a walk in a 3-1 loss to Baltimore in the final home game of the season at Yankee Stadium. Trying to become […]
23 hours ago
IOC transgender guidelines hailed but questions remain