Analysis: Rookie coaches need more time for job evaluations

Oct 28, 2021, 11:29 PM | Updated: Oct 29, 2021, 11:31 am
Philadelphia Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni speaks during a news conference at the NFL football te...

Philadelphia Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni speaks during a news conference at the NFL football team's training facility, Friday, Oct. 8, 2021, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Rourke)

(AP Photo/Matt Rourke)

Rookie head coaches usually inherit losing teams and are tasked with quickly building a winning culture in the NFL.

If they don’t get it done fast enough, it’s onto the next coach.

There’s no patience in sports, but judging guys before the midpoint of their first season is unfair.

Only one of the NFL’s seven first-year coaches has a winning record. Brandon Staley is off to a 4-2 start with the Los Angeles Chargers. It helps that he took over a team that finished 7-9 last year and already had a franchise quarterback in Justin Herbert.

Arthur Smith is 3-3 with the Atlanta Falcons, including three wins in the last four games. He has Matt Ryan, who looks like his old self after a rough start.

The five other rookie coaches are 5-28 combined. If owners listened to media and fans, some of these guys wouldn’t last through their first season.

Some people called for Urban Meyer to lose his job before he even stepped on a sideline with the Jacksonville Jaguars. He was criticized for hiring former Iowa assistant coach Chris Doyle and giving Tim Tebow an opportunity to resume his football career at a new position. Doyle resigned and Tebow was cut.

Meyer needed six tries to get his first win. That shouldn’t be a surprise considering the Jaguars (1-5) won only one game last season and had one winning season in the previous 13 years.

Meyer has Trevor Lawrence and little more. It’s doubtful he’ll ever match the success he had in college and he may not pan out in the pros, but Meyer deserves time to get things right — assuming he wants to stay in Jacksonville.

Dan Campbell was ripped right after his introductory news conference in Detroit. The former NFL tight end avoided coach-speak — “we’re going to bite a kneecap off” — in an emotionally charged virtual session that left critics debating his ability to lead the team.

Winning over the locker room is easier than winning games. The Lions are 0-7, though two losses came on long field goals as time expired, including Justin Tucker’s record-setting 66-yarder.

The Lions have had 13 double-digit loss seasons since 2001 and only one playoff victory since winning the NFL title in 1957. That track record of futility isn’t Campbell’s fault.

No one expected much from David Culley in Houston. The Texans (1-6) rebuild really starts when Deshaun Watson is traded.

Hope for Jets fans under Robert Saleh and rookie quarterback Zach Wilson has turned into more frustration. New York is 1-5, Wilson is injured and the team appears certain to miss the playoffs for the 11th straight season, the NFL’s longest active drought. But they’re smart enough to be patient with Saleh in the Big Apple.

No coach has faced the fire so far quite like Philadelphia’s Nick Sirianni. He takes even more heat for his wordy responses to questions than he does for his questionable playcalling.

They wanted him out after his first news conference when he seemed nervous and rambled. They blasted him when he talked about playing rock-paper-scissors with prospects before the draft. The condemnation reached Kotitian levels — nobody in Philly was criticized more than former Eagles coach Rich Kotite — this week when Sirianni told reporters he used a flower analogy in a message to his 2-5 team.

“The results aren’t there right now, but what’s going on here is that there’s growth under the soil,” Sirianni said. “I put a picture of a flower up, and it’s coming through the ground, and the roots are growing out. The roots are continuing to grow out. Everybody wants to see results. Shoot, nobody wants to see results more than us, right? We want to see results, too. But it’s really important that the foundation is being built and that the roots are growing out.

“And the only way the roots grow out every single day and they grow stronger and they grow better is if we all water, we all fertilize, we all do our part, each individual, each individual coach, each individual player, everybody in the building, that we do our part to water to make sure that, when it does pop out, it really pops out and it grows.”

If Staley made that comparison in Los Angeles, he would’ve been lauded for his insightful perspective. But that doesn’t work in fickle Philly. Not unless Sirianni wins. It won’t be easy with a roster bereft of talent due to several poor drafts over the past decade.

Sirianni may ultimately pay the price for the front office’s failures, but neither he nor any of the rookie coaches can be fairly evaluated after six or seven games.


Follow Rob Maaddi on Twitter at and his work can be found at


More AP NFL coverage: and

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Atlanta Braves's Ronald Acuna Jr. celebrates after scoring on an RBI single by Michael Harris II du...
Associated Press

Acuña delivers late, Braves outlast Phillies 8-7 in 11

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Ronald Acuña singled home the go-ahead run in the 11th inning and the Braves stayed close in the NL East race, outlasting the Phillies 8-7 Sunday in a game that took over six hours to complete because of a two-hour rain delay. “Our goal is to win the World Series again,” Acuna […]
18 hours ago
Green Bay Packers' Aaron Rodgers hugs Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Tom Brady after an NFL football game Su...
Associated Press

Rodgers throws for 2 TDs, Packers hold off Brady, Bucs 14-12

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) — Aaron Rodgers threw for 255 yards and two touchdowns, and the Green Bay Packers withstood a late rally led by Tom Brady to hold off the Tampa Bay Buccaneers for a 14-12 victory on Sunday. Rodgers tossed TD passes of 5 yards to Romeo Doubs and 6 yards to Allen Lazard […]
18 hours ago
New York Mets designated hitter Pete Alonso (20) reacts after a home run in the fourth inning of a ...
Associated Press

Alonso sets team RBI mark; Scherzer, Mets top A’s, hold lead

OAKLAND, Calif. (AP) — Pete Alonso homered, doubled and drove in five runs to set the team record for RBIs, Max Scherzer pitched six sharp innings and the New York Mets routed the Oakland Athletics 13-4 Sunday to hold their NL East lead. The Mets remained 1 1/2 games ahead of Atlanta. New York has […]
18 hours ago
Atlanta Falcons wide receiver Drake London, center, scores a touchdown during the second half of an...
Associated Press

Cordarrelle Patterson rumbles Falcons past Seahawks 27-23

SEATTLE (AP) — Cordarrelle Patterson rushed for a career-high 141 yards and one touchdown, Marcus Mariota threw a 14-yard TD to rookie Drake London in the second half, and the Atlanta Falcons picked up their first win of the season in beating the Seattle Seahawks 27-23 on Sunday. Patterson rumbled for 107 yards in the […]
18 hours ago
From left to right, Los Angeles Dodgers' Joey Gallo, Cody Bellinger and Mookie Betts celebrate a wi...
Associated Press

Grove helps Dodgers beat Cardinals 4-1 to clinch top NL seed

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Will Smith had two hits and Michael Grove pitched five solid innings to pick up his first career victory as the Los Angeles Dodgers clinched the No. 1 overall seed in the National League with 4-1 win over the St. Louis Cardinals on Sunday. Two days after reaching 700 home runs, […]
18 hours ago
Los Angeles Rams cornerback Jalen Ramsey (5) breaks up a pass intended for Arizona Cardinals tight ...
Associated Press

Rams continue dominance of Cardinals with 20-12 victory

GLENDALE, Ariz. (AP) — The Los Angeles Rams defense survived quite an onslaught on Sunday afternoon, defending 58 passing plays from Arizona’s Kyler Murray, who is notoriously hard to defend because of his ability to throw and run. Sean McVay wasn’t worried about giving up a few 10-yard passes or 5-yard runs, he just didn’t […]
18 hours ago
Analysis: Rookie coaches need more time for job evaluations