SEC officials under microscope after high-profile mistakes

Sep 22, 2021, 1:52 AM | Updated: 1:55 pm
Memphis receiver Calvin Austin III (4) returns a long punt against Mississippi State during an NCAA...

Memphis receiver Calvin Austin III (4) returns a long punt against Mississippi State during an NCAA college football game Saturday, Sept. 18, 2021, in Memphis, Tenn. (Patrick Lantrip/Daily Memphian via AP)

(Patrick Lantrip/Daily Memphian via AP)

Mississippi State coach Mike Leach was still being asked his thoughts Wednesday about the bizarre punt play in the fourth quarter of last week’s loss to Memphis, and two apparent mistakes — one of them acknowledged — by SEC officials.

Leach still wasn’t sure he wanted to pay to discuss them.

Regardless, the situation on the same Saturday as another significant error by SEC officials in Auburn’s loss at Penn State has put the men and women in stripes exactly where they never like to be: the spotlight.

“There is not a lot I can do differently. I clearly have some thoughts,” acknowledged Leach, whose team plays LSU this weekend. “I just have to figure out if I’m interest in making an investment in airing those thoughts. There is sort of a price to play this particular game. I kind of reserve the right to do that. It is still an option on the table.”

There might be no more difficult job in college football than officiating, particularly as teams have embraced wide open offenses, rapid substitutions, faster tempos and more exotic looks. And the reality is that the two plays that shone a nasty spotlight on the SEC on Saturday were but two of hundreds that its officials were forced to watch last weekend.

Still, they are also were mistakes egregious enough — particularly with instant replay available — that many coaches, players and fans are no doubt left wondering whether they can count on SEC officials to handle their games.

The more noteworthy mistakes, if only because it directly affected the outcome, came in the Bulldogs’ game.

It happened with Memphis leading 21-17 and 5:58 left in the fourth quarter. The Bulldogs punted and two players made contact with the ball in an attempt to down it, though neither ever actually possessed it, and the back judge waved his arms over his head to signal the play was dead. But with no whistle blowing, the Tigers’ Calvin Austin III alertly grabbed the ball and took off, running nearly the length of the field for a clinching touchdown.

The league said in a statement that Austin was allowed to pick the ball up because “the kicked ball remained live by rule, since it was not possessed by a player,” though more than a few would disagree with the interpretation. Where that was no gray area was this: The play should have been reversed because of the official’s signal.

“The subsequent review would have placed the ball at the spot where the signal was made,” the SEC said.

Leach said he was told Saturday that all plays are reviewed, and that the punt play had already been confirmed.

Evidently, the officials doing the review also missed the fact hat Memphis had two players on the field wearing the No. 4, which is also a violation and should have resulted in a 5-yard penalty.

“It is extremely disappointing when student-athletes are not fully in control of a game’s outcome,” Mississippi State athletic director John Cohen said, “especially when taking into consideration the time, effort and resources put into an officiating system created to eliminate human error on the field whenever possible.”

It didn’t eliminate human error in Happy Valley, either.

Early in the second quarter, the officials simply forgot an entire down — all of them — and Penn State was forced to punt on third down. Not surprisingly, Nittany Lions coach James Franklin was still baffled after the game.

Good thing they won or he might have been downright irate.

“I talked to all of them. They all agreed,” Franklin said. “I kept bringing them over and saying, ‘It’s not accurate.’ I don’t know what else I can tell you, but they all concurred with the officials. They got the headset, they talked to each other and they all agreed. They ran it by replay, they agreed as well. I don’t know what else I can do or what else I can say.”

The SEC had something to say: “The error was discovered during the media timeout that followed the punt,” the league said in a statement after the game, “and by rule it could not be corrected at that time.”

As far as Leach is concerned, at least make sure it’s correct next time.

“Our team doesn’t need to worry about that. We had ample opportunities to do things differently,” he said while choosing to take a diplomatic approach. “The biggest thing is we need to worry about ourselves and what we think is most important. (The players) don’t dwell on that at all. I handle that and our administration and the league — they handle that, and we focus on playing one play at a time. We’ve got to get better at that. That’s the biggest thing.”


More AP college football: and Sign up for the AP’s college football newsletter:

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Los Angeles Angels designated hitter Shohei Ohtani smiles while at third base during the first inni...
Associated Press

Ohtani agrees to $30 million deal for 2023 with Angels

ANAHEIM, Calif. (AP) — Shohei Ohtani has agreed to a $30 million deal with the Los Angeles Angels for the 2023 season in the two-way superstar’s final year of arbitration eligibility before free agency. The Angels announced the deal Saturday, avoiding a potentially complicated arbitration case with the 2021 AL MVP. Ohtani’s deal is fully […]
14 hours ago
Associated Press

Adebayo goes for 132 as St. Thomas runs to win over Marist

POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y. (AP) — Hope Adebayo rushed for 132 yards and scored one of St. Thomas of Minnesota’s three rushing touchdowns in a 38-24 victory over Marist on Saturday. St. Thomas (3-1) won its Pioneer League opener, churning out 242 yards on the ground to go with Cade Sexauer’s 218 yards passing with two touchdowns. […]
14 hours ago
Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa (1) is assisted off the field after he was injured during...
Associated Press

AP source: Union fires consultant who evaluated Tagovailoa

The NFL Players Association has fired the unaffiliated neurotrauma consultant who evaluated Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa after he stumbled off the field against Buffalo last Sunday, a person familiar with the decision told The Associated Press. The person who confirmed the firing, first reported by Pro Football Talk, spoke to the AP on condition […]
14 hours ago
TCU quarterback Max Duggan (15) throws a touchdown pass as Oklahoma defensive back Damond Harmon (1...
Associated Press

Duggan, TCU rout No. 18 Oklahoma 55-24 as Gabriel gets hurt

FORT WORTH, Texas (AP) — Max Duggan ran 67 yards for one of two touchdowns and threw for three scores, leading TCU to a 55-24 rout of No. 18 Oklahoma on Saturday in a second consecutive loss for new Sooners coach Brent Venables. OU quarterback Dillon Gabriel was knocked out of the game in the […]
14 hours ago
Mississippi safety AJ Finley (21) and linebacker Austin Keys (11) force a fumble from Kentucky quar...
Associated Press

No. 14 Mississippi beats mistake-prone No. 7 Kentucky 22-19

OXFORD, Miss. (AP) — Austin Keys and Jared Ivey each forced fumbles in the final three minutes, both inside the red zone, and No. 14 Mississippi held off No. 7 Kentucky 22-19 on Saturday. Keys and Ivey forced Wildcats quarterback Will Levis to fumble on consecutive possessions with AJ Finley and Tavius Robinson recovering both, […]
14 hours ago
New York Yankees' Aaron Judge reacts after striking out during the eighth inning of the team's base...
Associated Press

Judge stays at 61 homers on 61st anniversary of Maris’ 61st

NEW YORK (AP) — Aaron Judge went 0 for 2 with two walks and was hit by a pitch, remaining at 61 homers on the 61st anniversary of Roger Maris setting the American League record, and the New York Yankees beat the Baltimore Orioles 8-0 Saturday. Judge reached base leading off to spark a three-run […]
14 hours ago
SEC officials under microscope after high-profile mistakes