Ex-scout: Seahawks should have taken DE at 25

May 2, 2011, 6:59 PM | Updated: 7:08 pm
Heyward
Former NFL scout Dave Razzano thinks the Seahawks would have been better off taking Ohio State DE Cameron Heyward with the 25th pick. (AP)

By Brady Henderson

The Seahawks were criticized for their decision to use the 25th pick on OT James Carpenter, a player who wasn’t considered by draft analysts to be as good as other tackles still on the board and one who many believe could have been available in the second round.

If you’re a Seahawks fan tired of hearing the negative post-draft reviews, don’t look to former NFL scout Dave Razzano for a second opinion.

“I wasn’t particularly impressed with what they did,” Razzano told the Kevin Calabro show on Monday. “I probably would have gone defense first. But they get a big right tackle, obviously, in Carpenter. I thought that was a little early for him. … Instead of Carpenter in (the first round), I probably would have gone Cam Heyward, who went 31 to Pittsburgh.”

Razzano, who spent more than 20 years as a scout for the Rams, 49ers and Cardinals, said his grade for the Seahawks’ draft would be a D.

“And I love those guys … I really respect John Schneider,” he said. “But I just expected them to go defense.”

Seattle used six of it’s nine picks on defenders, but only after taking offensive linemen in the first and third rounds and trading out of the second. Mississippi State linebacker K.J. Wright (Rd. 4, No. 99 overall) was the first defender the Seahawks drafted.

In Razzano’s opinion, taking Carpenter at No. 25 wasn’t the biggest mistake of the draft. That honor belongs to the 49ers, who passed on a quarterback and took Missouri defensive end Aldon Smith with the No. 7 overall pick.

“I thought he was more of a late-second-round pick,” Razzano said of Smith. “Hopefully he pans out for them. I just don’t think he will.”

The best move? Razzano thinks it was Tennessee’s decision to use the eighth pick on Jake Locker, who Razzano believes was the best quarterback in the draft.

“I think it surprised some people, but again, when you really study him I think the guy can thrive and I thought he was much better than Blaine Gabbert, who went a couple picks later,” Razzano said.

You might also be interested in…

Dilfer: Tarvaris Jackson could be next Seahawks QB

Huard: Seahawks get an ‘incomplete’ for 2011 draft

Seahawks still left with QB questions after draft

Wyman & Bob

Seattle Seahawks

Seahawks Michael Jackson...
Brandon Gustafson

Huard: 3 positions the Seahawks could shake up soon

With the Seahawks at 1-2, what type of changes to personnel could we see moving forward? Brock Huard's keeping an eye on three spots.
12 hours ago
Seahawks Falcons...
Stacy Rost

Rost: Pressure mounting for Seahawks’ defense to show improvement

The Seahawks made the strides they needed on offense, but if that improvement doesn’t stretch to the defense, there won’t be much winning.
12 hours ago
Seahawks defense...
Brandon Gustafson

Seahawks’ offense gets plays it needs, but new D not cutting it

The Seahawks got back on track offensively against Atlanta, but the defense continues to struggle, and this year, it's in a new way.
1 day ago
Seahawks Falcons...
SeattleSports.com Staff

Seahawks Instant Reaction: Seattle Sports on 27-23 loss to Falcons

The voices of Seattle Sports weigh in on the Seahawks' 27-23 loss to the Atlanta Falcons on Sunday in Week 3 of the NFL season.
1 day ago
Seahawks Falcons...
Brent Stecker

Fast Facts: Seahawks’ comeback falls short, Falcons win 27-23

Seattle's defense broke a little more than it bent on Sunday, with the Atlanta Falcons coming away with a 27-23 victory at Lumen Field for their first win of the season.
1 day ago
Seahawks Justin Coleman...
Brandon Gustafson

Seahawks’ secondary depth thin as they take on Falcons in Week 3

The Seahawks have four members of their secondary, including nickel corner Justin Coleman, out when they host the Atlanta Falcons in a Week 3
1 day ago
Ex-scout: Seahawks should have taken DE at 25